Animal Collective gets asses moving
In the last five years or so, the usually Frankenstein-limbed members of the indie-rock-listening community remembered that they have asses. More to the point, they remembered that, sometimes, it’s fun to throw back your head, shut your eyes, and shake said backside like it was on fire.
Even in the more traditional realm of guitar/drum/bass rock, inciting the crowd to dance is seen more and more as a positive, even hip thing. But lest we be confused with the Pinks and Timberlakes of the world (we will always worry that we look ridiculous while dancing), we have to make the journey from our brain to our tail feather difficult. We need to be able to contemplate lyrics and time-signature changes and meaning; to gently stroke our artfully manicured mustaches before we can allow ourselves such base pleasures. But on Merriweather Post Pavilion, Animal Collective’s message seems to be, “Fuck all that.”
Nine albums and eight years in, it’s time to stop trying to figure out what the hell Animal Collective—vocalist/guitarist Avey Tare, percussionist/vocalist Panda Bear and knob-twiddler Geologist—is, and just enjoy the orgasmic rush of danceable rock. After all, hands are meant not to be jettisoned up in frustration at dead-end lyrics, but thrown in the air as if you just didn’t care.
From the gurgling heartbeat of “In The Flowers”—where a sampled, garbled voice seems to be saying “I’mna dance,” and Tare drunkenly warbles about longing to leave his body for the night—this is an album made for the waist down. Tare’s proclamation sets free the song’s pulsating body, a dreamy, floating chorus of voices and gently picked strings that glides on top of a booming, lock-step bass thud.
And nothing goes better with sweaty dancefloor gyrations than sex and love and ladies, themes that carry two of Merriweather’s best tracks, “My Girls” and “Summertime Clothes.” The former is a loose-limbed jumping jack of a fem-positive pop song that sounds somewhere between Eno and Byrne’s My Life in the Bush of Ghosts and The Spice Girls’ Spiceworld. It’s a musical chigger that burrows deep and won’t leave. “Summertime Clothes” is similarly addictive, a robo-tripping love song where—over a bouncing low end and weird harpsichord crescendos—Tare and Panda Bear’s harmonies sound absolutely Shins-esque.
Not everything is hearts and Ketamine, though. Merriweather’s middle gets a bit dirgey. The echo-chamber effect on “Daily Routine” borders on the boring; “Bluish” threatens to meander until Avey Tare’s killer chorus rips the Band-Aid off. And then there’s Animal Collective’s unquenchable penchant for experimentation. “Guys Eyes” recycles Panda’s voice what seems like a billion times until he’s singing over himself in 18-part harmony, finally validating all those once-puzzling Beach Boys comparisons. “Lion In A Coma” is built on a looped African jaw harp and an impossible-to-step-to 9/4 beat.
Interesting sign posts, for sure—the kind of thing Collective completists live for. But thankfully the band doesn’t forget the sampled mantra that started this whole journey: I’mna dance. As proof, they close the album with “Brothersport.” Shimmying its way to life in a clash of mechanized tribal drumming and Afrobeat-lite choral rounds that sound like Fela Kuti making love to his 27 robotic wives, the song soon dissolves into a racket of assembly-line noises before returning to rapid-fire three-part harmonies that finally culminate in an overblown explosion of big-beat rave. It’s the kind of epic track that probably depletes your serotonin levels while you listen.
But this is the new indie ethos: Don’t think; dance. Like Tare says on “My Girls,” “I don’t mean to seem like I care about material things like my social stance, I just want four walls and adobe slats for my girls.”
I have absolutely no idea what that means, and I don’t care—print it up, put it on a T-shirt and hand me that glow stick.
Listen to Animal Collective's "Brothersport" from Merriweather Post Pavilion:


im sorry. i love this album, but this was the worst written review ive ever read.
seriously, please don't let this person write another review ever again.
print it up and put it on a t-shirt
the lyrics you posted for My Girls are terribly wrong. please advise.
Seriously, this is awful (the review not the album).
Does this really refer to Avey Tare as a she?
"Once puzzling Beach Boys comparisons?" ??? Have you heard Person Pitch?
"Danceable rock"???
I could go on...
Can you guys let me write reviews? I guarantee I can do better.
I didn't mind the review so much. It's pretty bold, but it works. I don't know why, but I'm glad Paste is publishing the word "fuck" now. Really though, the line about Fela Kuti's 27 robotic wives is oddly appropriate.
Thanks for the catch on Avey Tare, John. Fixed here and we'll have a retraction in the March issue.
Thanks, Austin. I always feel guilty after posting a ranting comment. So, I will say that I don't think the writing in this review is bad. I actually like the style and some of the metaphors/comparisons. But it seems misinformed in numerous places, which takes away from its validity.
The dance music comparison totally misses the point. Why not put this album in the proper context of Animal Collective's catalogue instead of the embarassingly misplacing it within the tradition of Dan Deacon and Girl Talk? Seems like a lazy review to me, a review that "stopped trying to figure out what the hell Animal Collective is about" and as a result "confused (them) with the Pinks and Timberlakes of the world."
...pretty weak review, indeed.
"Shimmying its way to life in a clash of mechanized tribal drumming and Afrobeat-lite choral rounds that sound like Fela Kuti making love to his 27 robotic wives, the song soon dissolves into a racket of assembly-line noises before returning to rapid-fire three-part harmonies that finally culminate in an overblown explosion of big-beat rave."
yesss
now if only this track was 15 minutes long like most fela kuti songs, it would truly rock
What do you expect from a mag that voted She & Him as album of the year??? This review is a complete joke. You should let random fans write in, we all can do better than this clown.
"Like Tare says on “My Girls,” “I don’t mean to seem like I care about material things like my social stance, I just want four walls and adobe slats for my girls.” I have absolutely no idea what that means, and I don’t care—print it up, put it on a T-shirt and hand me that glow stick."
That has to be the most hilarious closing statement in a review ever. I can't conceive an editor actually red that and decided to print it. It isn't even fact-checked. Panda Bear sings "My Girls", singing about his wife and daughter. Sigh.
A new low for the mag.
This review made me spew in my mouth.
I'm not even an animal collective fan, but I have listened to the record and its great. This review, however, is terrible, as many others have pointed out. "Shins-esque" huh? Has the reviewer ever listened to music made prior to 2001? He totally dismisses the record as "Animal Collective's dance record" which is missing the point entirely. He lists songs in the middle like "Bluish" as low points, when the middle is actually the most beautiful part of the record. Maybe he was too busy trying to compare the record to Girl Talk and the Shins to actually carefully listen to it. Paste, if you care about having any sort of credibility, you will never let this man write reviews again.
I agree, poor review. It's as if the author heard the word "dance" in "In the Flowers" and, having no other source of inspiration, attempted to write an article off of that. If this were a Strokes review, it might make more sense.
"My Girls" is hardly about sex (I doubt Tare is into incest), and the line is "...status.../...slabs...", not "...stance.../...slats...".
Now, this is this guy's opinion, and I respect that. Yet it's apparent that no one on the Paste editing staff has heard Merriweather. They didn't bother to fact-check, and anyone familiar with AC should know that this simply misses the point.
Merriweather, like Strawberry Jam, is all about the repeated listen. Subsequent listens uncover new aspects each time, and that's what makes it great. My first reaction is hardly to "grab my glowsticks."
This guy definitely knows his music history, but I don't think he's up to modern times. Reviewers listen to music professionally, and they usually know their stuff better than I do. Bart simply disappoints.
So, is anyone going to site "taste" as Merriweath's climax or did your iPod shuffle over that track? The finale chorus leaves your brain on the floor - visceral jamming ensues.
agreed. this was an awfully written article for such a fantastic record. just plain terrible.
"I have absolutely no idea what that means, and I don’t care—print it up, put it on a T-shirt and hand me that glow stick."
Dear Paste,
Hire better people.
Sincerely,
Earth
Hate to continue on the meta-review theme, but... the harpsichord the reviewer refers to would be arpeggios, not crescendos.
this is a pretty shitty review. it reads like something that should be on pitchfork...
come on paste!!!
great record. i guess the effort to do something more streamlined and melodic leaves it just barely on the cusp of mainstream-indie appeal, so these kind of confused reviews are bound to spring up.
i dont see why any of you expect much from paste, its like cosmo for music
why does he mention girl talk. what the hell does he have to do with this. dan deacon i can understand. but they should be mentioning steve reich and terry riley and boredoms and detroit techno artists, and the incredible string band, and etc etc
I'm wondering how many of Paste's regular freelancers are pissed that the review for such a great album went to this guy. The fact that a lot of Paste readers only have passing familiarity with Animal Collective is not an excuse or Person Pitch would have gotten the same treatment. This just bleeds ignorance.
Man, you dont have a heart
I just have to say I'm glad I'm not the only one who thought the Paste review of this incredible record was downright shameful...In fact, I'd say its the worst review I've read in this fine magazine.
How could Mr. Blasengame "have absolutely no idea what ["My Girls"] means"...? It was driving me crazy reading the blasted review.
Also, a note to Paste editors: Dropping f-bombs in reviews doesn't make you ironic or cool; grow up, your magazine is better than that.
"But lest we be confused with the Pinks and Timberlakes of the world (we will always worry that we look ridiculous while dancing), we have to make the journey from our brain to our tail feather difficult."
Maybe it's time to start taking a poll on what the worst sentence in this unspeakably awful review is. I'm voting the above. The fact that I, as reader, am roped into the author of this drivel's "we" makes me feel really, really creepy. Not to mention: tail feather.
So, misidentified members, misidentified genders of members, incorrect lyrics, terrible comparisons, clear ignorance of the artist's back-catalogue, hammering an entire album into the one idea you have of it, embarrassing use of colloquialisms, general disregard for critical thought, complete lack of analysis, problems with the basics of language... anything we're missing?
Ok, the review isn't that great, but really, this record is quite danceable. AC were inspired a lot by dance and hip hop for this record, and it shows. This album is basically pop and dance, but with an equal focus on interesting soundscapes. That doesn't make it bad, and people are showing their prejudice against the genres by the way they are acting. And the lyrics clearly aren't as important as the music on this album, the author doesn't need to comprehend them (although in this case I don't see how you couldn't). If you can't dance to this record, you are a boring person.