
![]()
The Raconteurs' Jack White at the New American Music Union Festival, photo by C.C. Chapman
Last weekend, American Eagle Outfitters launched its inaugu
ral music festival, New American Music Union, in the SouthSide Works area of Pittsburgh. A sold-out crowd of 10,000 was treated to performances from Bob Dylan, The Raconteurs, Gnarls Barkley, The Roots and Spoon, among others, all under the curation of Red Hot Chili Pepper Anthony Kiedis.
The highlight of the weekend was the wildly energetic, funky and
innovative performance from The Roots to close out Friday night. I'd
heard what an amazing live band they were, but this was my first time
experiencing that. And they did not disappoint. All of these gentlemen
are consummate musicians with wide-ranging influences (which will not
come as a surprise to those who know the band or who read our cover
story with ?uestlove). Their set was so kinetic and varied (across
songs and within songs) that they were the only band leaving me wanting
more. If jam bands had just half the dynamism of The Roots, I might
tolerate it better. The diverse crowd (in age and ethnicity) seemed to
enjoy the band every bit as much as I did.
The Raconteurs were another crowd favorite. The band has gelled well
and puts on a great show. The Black Keys caught many by surprise with
their 2-person assault. They are always engaging. The only real
disappointment was Dylan. His voice is so far gone that it's hard to
decipher the lyrics any more. And while his band is always tight, he
continues to apply the same sheen to the arrangements of all his
songs. The current jazz-lick, mid-tempo rockabilly is an improvement
over the Western swing of a couple years ago, but it's still lacking.
I admire him for reworking his classics and not just resting on his stature, but the new arrangements and
melodies just don't serve his songs. I've seen his Bobness four times
in the past decade. The first, at Madison Square Gardens, was
transcendent. The next two, at Atlanta's Tabernacle and Austin's ACL
Festival, were dismal. This performance was merely disappointing.
The festival as a whole was a great success. It's rare that you ever see this many great acts perform for 10,000 people and only $25 or
$50. In addition to the main stage acts, the festival showcased 15
college bands from across the country. The Black Fourtys, from the
University of Southern Illinois, won the competition. The college
bands and many of the other activities (such as the peddle-to-charge
cellphone charging station) were located outside the festival grounds
and free to the community. All ticket-holders also received a free festival t-shirt and a water bottle for filling on festival grounds (green was an important theme for the fest).
I have a soft-spot for smaller community-centered festivals. It's nice
to watch simply watch bands, without fighting crowds of tens of
thousands to get to the festival, to get through the gates, to get
close to the stage. Seeing these bands without even needing a video
monitor (not provided) was a nice change of pace. To have
this with the caliber of bands Kiedis and AE attracted is truly
remarkable.
Videos of many of the performances are available at American Eagle.


It really was a cool festival. I agree with the author about The Roots, but I couldn't disagree more about Dylan. His voice isn't shot; it just so happens to be different than it was forty five years ago. he doesn't really look at his music as sentimentally as we may, but he always keeps it interesting.
Kiedis at curator? That's pretty cool.
Green seems to be the way to go these days for festivals and as I read reviews like your's that mention "green as the theme" I wonder when green will not be just a marketing tool and simply an expected standard. Rothbury Festival banked their entire festival on the sustainablely-minded fan and it will be interesting to see what festivals do next year to stand out, since the artists bills don't make festivals unique anymore.
Nice review and thanks Tim!
http://www.ink19.com/issues/august2008/eventReviews/rothburyMusicFestival.html
Good review, but I very much disagree with your comments about Dylan. I think this "new" voice is cool and interesting. I thought he kicked ass.
Dylan's playing and band sounded solid; however, despite his truly deserved legendary status and his multitude of great songs, Dylan's inscrutable voice is what ruined his show, for me at least (and I like his '60s/early '70s-era voice). He sounded like a dying frog mating with Bobcat Goldthwaite. Dylan should think about letting others sing his great songs while he and his band play. Someone in his inner circle should tell him this. His voice aside, the festival was a resounding success--especially the Black Keys, the Roots, and Spoon. Raconteurs were solid classic rock (almost too much so, but still good). Overall, even though I unfortunately missed Gnarls, it was the best festival I've been to in years. I took the shuttle from the arena to the Hot Metal Bridge and walked over the river gazing at the cityscape with the sun bouncing off the water and buildings. No traffic hassles, just a great way to enter a killer show.