Okay, the band names on this list don't have to be made entirely
of consonants. We let a couple of numerals
sneak in because the artists were just too good to ignore, but we punished the
artists for their lack of semantic ingenuity. We drew a hard line and excluded
bands like CSS, because they rely on acronyms to make their name. We also
excluded bands like Styx, because they suck.
Overall, we gave points for artistic excellence and willful
exclusion of vowels. It takes a certain creativity to make any good band name.
But to make one using only consonants? Well, that suggests a band with
tremendous linguistic ambition, or maybe just too much time on its hands.
- M83 - Anthony Gonzalez's music comes transmitted with this
galaxy-inspired moniker that's not too high in nomenclatural innovation
(two numerals?! a real-world referent?!) but for such mesmerizing shoegaze
electronics, we'll allow it.
Musical quality: 6
Semantic ingenuity: 3
Total: 9
- B52s -
The best party band of all time should have been named Planet Claire.
Musical quality: 10
Semantic ingenuity: 1
Total: 11
- XTC -
Not a particularly ingenious band name. But without XTC, one of our
favorite genres
—jangle pop —would be seriously diminished.
Musical quality: 9
Semantic ingenuity: 3
Total: 12
4. MGMT -
For its willful and constantly defended
exclusion of vowels from its official name, we acknowledge this
electro-pop duo. For their insistence that listeners pronounce it M-G-M-T,
we appreciate these guys. For their hip, tripped-out boogies, we place them on a
pedestal.
Musical quality: 6
Semantic ingenuity: 8
Total: 14
Musical quality: 8
Semantic ingenuity: 7
Total: 15
- BLK
JKS - According to our Emergent story on the band back in August, the JKS
got their name from a wild weed. But the crammed-together letters evoke so
much more. And any day now, they'll make a debut record that lives up to
the cleverness of their name.
Musical quality: 7
Semantic ingenuity: 9
1. Lynyrd Skynyrd - On top of inventing Southern rock, they also anticipated—make that instigated—the entire vowel dropping movement.
Musical quality: 7
Semantic ingenuity: 10
Total: 17
Who did we miss?

Where Have All The Weird Girls Gone?…

You forgot DNTL. He was immediately the first artist I thought of. I don't know where he ranks on your artistic measurement scale, but I think he's pretty cool.
KMFDM. And a honorable mention to Prince for dispensing with vowels AND consonants for a chunk of his career.
Oh yeah: What about "M" ("Pop Music")?
Chk Chk Chk
Hate to say it, folks, but I believe "y" would be a vowel in "Lynyrd Skynyrd." Remember, vowels are a, e, i, o, u -- and SOMETIMES y and w. It is a vowel when it takes the sound of an "i" (as in Skynyrd or Styx) and a consonant in words like yellow. Which means the honor of "instigators" of all-consonant bands probably should go to XTC. I may be wrong. Any English teachers out there care to dispute this?
Im a fan of "!!!", which fills the no vowel idea firstly through that, or what they go by to be able to be googled, "chk chk chk"
BR5-49 should definitely be on this list.