Page 1 of 4
In his Best Live Music Acts of 2008 list, Paste editor-in-chief Josh Jackson wrote the following:
“On any given night, on any city in America, there’s a band or a singer/songwriter transcending the usual concert experience. At the most basic, they’re doing the same thing as thousands of others that same night—standing on stage, singing and playing some instruments. But there’s something about the way they’re doing it—the way the lights compliment the sound, the way they involve the audience, the way their music connects directly to your soul, the way they make you know that there’s no place they’d rather be than with you, and the feeling becomes mutual. The audience will remember that night for a long time, and the next time they purchase a concert ticket, it will be with the hope to see something as special.”
For this list, the Paste staff argued, voted and argued again to find the 20 acts from this decade that evoked the feeling described above. Below is what we came up with. Let us know what we missed:

[Above: Photo by Rob Inderrieden]
20. TV on the Radio
Come for the gloriously frenetic songs that have been rewritten for the stage, stay for Tunde Adebimpe’s slithering, hypnotic dance moves. He’s arguably the frontman of the decade, and his bandmates know this; it’s why they play so hard. Austin L. Ray

[Above: Photo by Rob Inderrieden]
19. Of Montreal
With an endlessly inventive stage show to match its inspired glam-pop tunes, Of Montreal is a concert experience unlike any other. As the band tears through its whimsical yet danceable anthems, ninjas lurk in the wings and masked body-suited drones prowl the stage brandishing heads impaled on spears. Last time I saw them, at show’s climax, frontman Kevin Barnes emerged almost entirely naked from a coffin full of shaving cream. The band’s über-creative, anything-goes, artistically immersive performances have to be seen to be believed. Steve LaBate

[Above: Photo by Jon Gitchoff]
18. Pixies
One of the best live bands of the 1980s, the Pixies have set the standard of what a reunion tour can be. Playing to much larger crowds than when I saw them in 1989, Black Francis, Kim Deal and the gang seemed like they always belonged on the big stage. The band can still turn on a dime from quiet beautiful melodies to balls-to-the-wall rock, with Francis/Frank Black screaming his heart out to tunes from classics like Surfer Rosa and Doolittle. Josh Jackson

[Above: Photo by Jason McElweenie]
17. The Decemberists
Eight years ago, the idea of this rag-tag band of Portlanders ever effectively transitioning their whimsical, multi-instrumental live show from the tiny stages of Rose City clubs to expansive music halls across the country seemed about as likely as anyone ever rhyming “legionnaire” with “Frigidaire,” but The Decemberists did both with glorious panache. And as the band’s albums have grown more ambitious, so have their performances, balancing the whale costumes and sing-alongs of its early shows with an ever more epic, eclectic vision of the future. Rachael Maddux

[Above: Photo by Joseph Longo]
16. Ted Leo
The New Jersey punk rocker is unafraid to get a little blood on the stage or a little percussion in the crowd, echoing The Jam, Elvis Costello and The Clash along the way. His between-song banter is topped only by his status as one of the nicest dudes in the history of rock ‘n’ roll. Come prepared to be entertained. Austin L. Ray



Just a few bands I saw this decade that deserve to be on the list:
Andrew W.K.-Never before have I seen children dancing on stage while the single-most dangerous mosh pit I've ever seen forms as Andrew jumps right into it.
Beck-Especially on his Guero tour, his traveling band recreates his manic albums with perfection, yet makes it all seem spontaneous.
Explosions in the Sky-Coming off like the American Sigur Ros, EitS can emotionally move an audience while also making them bang their heads, all while not saying a word.
Girl Talk-Never before has a man with just a computer and a toilet paper cannon made an audience feel so much like one of the band.
Yeah Yeah Yeahs-Karen O became our generation's Joan Jett, but better, mostly by her incredible stage show while Nick and Brian keep the madness in sync.
Pretty good list; although there seems to be too much focus on recent tours. I know this could come down to personal preference; however, some very notable exclusions include:
1) Daft Punk - Their Alive tour was heralded by many as one of the best recent tours. Their show at Coachella amazed the masses. Complete with the lighted pyramid set and robotic costumes, Daft Punk proved that an electronica duo can really put on a great show and keep the crowd enthused. I know their show at Lollapalooza was definitely one of the best I have ever seen.
2) Gogol Bordello - These guys were extremely popular on tour over 2007 and 2008. With Eugene's crazy antics - including crowd surfing in a drum, playing the guitar on his back, sitting on the front of the stage, drumming on the microphone with a bucket, or smashing the microphone after the set - as well as the rest of the gypsies up on stage dancing around, you would think the music would lack. But it didn't, and it carried out live even better than on CD.
3) Phish - Alright, I'm not a Phish fan, but they're almost as much as a given for this category as the Flaming Lips. They were born to play live music. Between hosting their own festivals, playing sets made up entirely on an album from another artist being covered, playing for four hours straight into the wee morning hours, inciting glow stick wars, etc., it's hard to see this band left off the list for any reason besides the fact that they're not as "hip" as the other bands listed.
Great list, gang. I might only add:
Art Brut - Frontman/instigator Eddie Argos takes his role as a DC Comics-touting Bacchus very seriously, and will run laps through the middle of the crowd to get face time with everyone. Meanwhile, his bandmates just let the hooks fly. By the end of an Art Brut show, even introverts dragged there by their well-meaning friends are screaming, drunken lunatics.
Bruce Springsteen should be number 1 no question. He's been doing it since the early 70s and does it better than anyone else out there still.
agreed... great list... TVOTR and Wilco were both my favorite concerts of the past two years.
i also think the following should (or could) be included:
MIA - her moves are contagious, her dj's are amazing, her songs are even better live and she engages the audience to the point where 50 strong get to join her on stage
Metric - no one beats emily haines on stage, i promise (even if you don't love their music)
Explosions In The Sky - exactly what was said above, they really get to you without even saying a word
Good list. Pearl Jam? Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds?
How do you not have Muse on here??? Seeing their show in Lollapalooza in '07 was like a religious experience! I was expecting it to be number one and was shocked when I saw Arcade fire there. I mean maybe not number one but at least put them somewhere. Their shows are mind blowing, they go all out and use fog machines, strobe lights, giant TV screens, balloons etc. Not to mention they're one of the best bands out there. Also, I'm from Barcelona was a lot of fun live seeing how they have 29 members or something.
I am so proud to say I have seen all three of the top 3, and agree, they deserve it. Those shows changed my life. LCD Soundsystem opened for Arcade Fire when I saw them... amazing.
I get goosebumps just thinking about Nine Inch Nails live....
Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you for recognizing the Polyphonic Spree. One of the best experiences of my life seeing them live! It's a shame Train isn't on your list. They put a lot of heart into their performances.
I need to see the Flaming Lips...
monotonix and dan deacon have put on some of the craziest shows iv seen even if it's a little out there.
avett brothers are great live, but i think old crow medicine show does it better if you want to put a "bluegrass-ish" band up there.
ryan adams? it's amazing how strong his voice is live, especially with the recent tour of a more acoustic based and mellow "blue cave" shows.
dirty projectors have sold a lot of people based on their live shows.
I Drive-By Truckers and Josh Ritter should be on that list.
There are quite a few artists that I would list before those that you mentioned, but I think the best live performer of this decade is unquestionably by Vic Chesnutt.
I've been waiting for this list! Thank you! Lots of great acts on here and you're dead on for 1-3 but Ted Leo is WAY too low. ;)
I agree with the people below who mentioned Pearl Jam, Art Brut (who I actually saw outdo The Hold Steady...not an easy feat), Daft Punk and Gogol Bordello. Those shows were all spectacular. Also great shows:
The Dismemberment Plan. Yes, they broke up in 2003 but what a fantastic show they put on.
Sonic Youth. I saw them on the Sonic Nurse tour knowing zero songs on that album and they blew my mind.
The Rapture. Everyone in the band is a dancing bouncing machine but the saxophone player in particular has some dance moves that should be illegal...while playing the sax!
LCD Soundsystem. I was at the same show in New York where they opened for the Arcade Fire and I didn't expect that sort of stage presence from James Murphy and company but I sure got it.
Les Savy Fav. Mostly because Tim Harrington is completely insane and he switches up what costumes and skits he performs for every show.
I agree with the list, but must say I've only scene Wilco, Sigur Ros, My Morning Jacket, Decemberists, Sufjan Stevens, and Radiohead. Wilco is definitely my favorite band to see live, but Jeff Tweedy solo is just as good but on a different level.
I would like to include the following bands-
Andrew Bird
Rosie Thomas
Black Rebel Motorcycle Club
Great Lake Swimmers
Aqualung
I enjoyed the list, but I can't see how you can make a list of the best live acts of this decade and not include The Roots. These guys spent most of the of this decade playing 200 shows a year. They bring so much energy, variety and creativity to whatever songs they choose to play live. I saw them when they opened for Erykah Badu and they absolutely stole the show.
I agree with the list, but must say I've only scene Wilco, Sigur Ros, My Morning Jacket, Decemberists, Sufjan Stevens, and Radiohead. Wilco is definitely my favorite band to see live, but Jeff Tweedy solo is just as good but on a different level.
I would like to include the following bands-
Andrew Bird
Rosie Thomas
Black Rebel Motorcycle Club
Great Lake Swimmers
Aqualung
Wow, where's Daft Punk on this list?!
My top three of your list would be U2, Bruce, and Wilco... I would add:
Ryan Adams - he's put on so many different types of shows and does grateful dead better than wilco... I assume he's not on because he's not the most charming guy on earth.
Black Crowes - have re-invented themselves and are one of the top 5 shows I've ever seen. The addition of Luther Dickinson as lead guitar made them even better...
Stephen Kellogg and the Sixers - always the most fun I have at a show every year. Great songs and performances
Damien Rice - extreme intimacy and beauty
Pearl Jam - duh.
Prince
The Roots
You missed at least 3 - Ellery, Over The Rhine, and OMG Leonard Cohen. Seeing that man live on this tour, I'm convinced he's going to outlive us all.
i am so very tired of these lists...i suppose there are some that think if you work for paste you must be a part of this bastion of musical knowledge and taste, but i could care less. how about some articles?
editor josh: find a better use of your staff's time!
Arcade Fire is definitely impressive live. Too bad they're so boring recorded.
Granted they tour much this decade, but Belle & Sebastian is the best band I have ever seen live. It is one of the few times in my life I felt my life would be complete if it ended right after a show. It's the closest I've ever had to a revelation.
I could see Damian Jurardo everyday for a year and not get tired of him. Witty, warm, inviting: truly one of the great performers of our time.
Architecture in Helsinki are also pure magic.
Last, but definitely not least Castledoor. Just emerging on the national scene, the LA band put on shows that rival many a seasoned musician.
The White Stripes??????? C'mon man.
a good list overall. personally i'm not a fan of springsteen, but i can see where he might be exciting live.
my nomination for the list is Cloud Cult. i saw them in a small club in 2007 and it was a transcendental experience. that they have 2 artists who travel with the band to create 2 pieces of art inspired by each evening's performance is reason enough to put them on the list. but frontman Craig Minowa's style of singing is so emotionally charged that, as a spectator, it's impossible not to get drawn in. and they are the eco-friendliest band you'll ever meet! what's not to love?
So-so list.
The glaring omission THE HIVES. By Far the most energized and exciting live act out there today.
fun. or ghostland observatory either one of these bands live are going to chang your life.
I've seen nearly all of the groups/artists you list, and feel you have left out quite a few transcendent performers:
- Leonard Cohen - his touring over the last two years has been one magnificent show after another.
- Josh Ritter - seen him solo, with a band, and with a bunch of cellos. Always holds the audience rapt. The Animal Years tour was a special highlight.
- Ryan Adams - sometimes great, sometimes so-so. When he's on, he's one of the best. Remember him touring with Ollabelle - playing lead guitar for them - then a set with his band.
- The Roots - these guys are amazing live - the only band I've seen who take the roof off symphony hall, and their shows are so varied - little James Brown mini-sets, their version of Masters of War, and the list goes on.
- Patti Smith - still channelling some sort of deep mystical power.
- Manu Chao - didn't tour North America a lot, but every show was outstanding.
And there are many others - Elvis Costello is still a great performer, the Black Crowes have been great since Luther Dickinson joined (and I love the North Mississippi All-Stars live), Phil Lesh and friends have been great, especially the Jackie Greene/Larry Campbell grouping, Bob Dylan was always strong and best with Charlie Sexton and Larry Campbell, to name a few.
There's only one band ahead of Arcade Fire for my "List of Bands to See Before I Die" list. They're either missing from this list due to some weird oversight or you guys just haven't seen Disc 1 of the Abbatoir Blues Tour 4 Disc Set.
Seriously.
Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds.
Other great live acts I caught that were excluded from this list: Okkervil River, The Swell Season, Murder By Death, The Thermals, Other Lives, Elvis Perkins in Dearland, The Walkmen, The National, Flight of the Conchords, Old Crow Medicine Show, WHY?, The Walkmen and The Black Lips
Glaring omissions:
Bon Iver, Muse, Gogol Bordello, The Frames, The Hives, Fucked Up, Sonic Youth, Any band with Jack White or Nick Cave in it, Franz Ferdinand, Two Gallants, Gorillaz, Josh Ritter, Andrew WK, Ben Folds, The Roots, Shearwater, The Black Keys, Beck, The Mooney Suzuki, The Mountain Goats, Black Rebel Motorcycle Club, Andrew Bird, and Gnarls Barkley
Seriously, Pearl Jam isn't even mentioned at all?
One of the best live shows you will ever see. How many bands can say they play different set lists for every show, including cameos from big name bands here and there?!
Keane should have been on this :( But I agree on everyone else already here.
Wait, seriously?? That list can't be right.
How about:
#1 The White Stripes
#2 The Dead Weather
#3 The Raconteurs
Yeh, that's more like it. I've seen all of those bands at least three times each, and each time it was awesome to stunning to mindblowing.
So where have you guys been hiding out when Jack White came to town?? The man is a force of nature unto himself, all thunder and lightning bolts and howling storms and raging torrential outpour of primal blues rock. You been missing out on all that??
Ben Folds? Seriously. I mean, I know you guys flipped your shit too when Ben Folds Five got back together. And there's no denying Folds' skills on the keys, nor his live energy.
I will second the nod for Cloud Cult. Amazing experience. SO thrilled to see The Polyphonic Spree rank so high.
The fact that Pearl Jam isn't on here makes this a bullshit list.
Decent list, although I would question why The Killers didn't make the cut.
I see a lot of live music and have done so for over 25 years, and there are three bands that are beyond compare when it comes to professionalism, bang for your buck, and their music-My Morning Jacket, Wilco, and The Decemberists. It's easy to justify hopping on a plane or driving five hours to see any of them. There are other really good live acts that I go out of my way to see, but they don't deliver at the same level at these three. Bands that fill huge stadiums don't do it for me (U2, Pearl Jam, The Boss). I need intimacy. The Avett Brothers, The Black Crowes (after nearly 20 years!), Band of Horses, The Flaming Lips, Drive by Truckers, and The Black Keys also know how to deliver the goods.