All ThatSaturday Night LiveSNLAll ThatSNLAll That
Angelique Bates (1994-1996)
Then: Was one half of "Cooking with Randy & Mandy."
Now: Seems to be concentrating on her hip-hop career (she performs as Alizay) but she's also acted a little, including in the slasher flick Sisters, co-starring her All That castmates Katrina Johnson and Alisa Reyes.
Katrina Johnson (1994-1997)
Then: Played an adorable shyster in the "Lemonade Scammer" sketches.
Now: According to her IMDb profile, became a flight attendant shortly after leaving All That and has since retired from acting to live in Las Vegas with her boyfriend. But the same page says she appeared in the likely-rightfully-obscure 2009 flick She's a Fox, and then there's Sisters, so maybe she just wishes she retired?