“This is the most honest that I’ve gotten. This is as close [as I’ve come] to who I think I am,” says Rilo Kiley’s Jenny Lewis of her first solo album, pausing for a pensive moment. “That’s true right now, anyway,” she laughs. “I might change a few years down the road.”
Though elements of country, soul and gospel have poked through the seams of Lewis’ Rilo Kiley songs since she and guitarist Blake Sennett formed the band in 1998, the homespun intimacy of the stripped-down Rabbit Fur Coat might surprise those who only know her as the photogenic frontwoman of the band that opened for Coldplay. But to call it a departure seems inaccurate, as Lewis contends this album’s roots are buried deep inside her musical DNA, ingrained in the formative musical experiences of her childhood.
“I think there were a couple records that maybe because of the time in my life when I heard them for the first time, they still resonate with me, because I think of happy times growing up,” she says, explaining the inspiration for the warm, organic tones of her new record. “Laura Nyro [and] LaBelle’s Gonna Take a Miracle record was played a lot in the house growing up, and I was always fascinated with the backup vocals … And then, more recently, New Morning by Bob Dylan is one of my favorite records. Obviously, he’s awesome, but I love that one sound, as opposed to all of his other records.”
Recorded in 10 days (with first takes and spontaneity emphasized), Rabbit Fur Coat started taking shape after Lewis realized the album’s title track—a dreamlike marriage of Lewis Carroll imagery and Bobbi Gentry storytelling—wouldn’t fit on Rilo Kiley’s 2004 breakthrough, More Adventurous.
“That was the first of a batch of new songs that I started to write, really, without any intention. I just didn’t know where they’d go,” she explains. “However, I did know that there is quite a long period of time between when you write a song and record it, and I thought there was going to be a long time until the next Rilo Kiley record and that it might be a good opportunity to record some songs. And then Conor [Oberst] started his label a couple of years ago and said that if I ever wanted to make a solo record, he wanted to put it out, which I remember thinking was kind of far-fetched at the time. But remembering that, I thought, well, I have these songs and I should do something with them.”
A Collaborative ‘Solo Project’
With producer Mike Mogis (Bright Eyes, Rilo Kiley) and singer/songwriter M. Ward at the helm for this record, other friends were brought in to enhance the sonic backdrop. Lewis even drew some inspiration from another all-star project, enlisting Death Cab for Cutie’s Ben Gibbard, Bright Eyes’ Conor Oberst and M. Ward to trade verses on Traveling Wilburys classic “Handle With Care.”
As much as the album benefits from its collaborative spirit, Lewis remains the dominant personality; her songwriting has never been so boldly autobiographical. “It’s hard to talk about,” she says, sounding frustrated. “I should have prepped myself a little better for these personal questions. It’s hard to talk about those songs that way, especially when the songs are personal. I haven’t found a great way to deflect those questions yet. Like when someone asks me, ‘Is that song about your mother?’ I could say, ‘No, it’s about your mother,’” she laughs, then trails into an awkward pause. “Well, I can say that the part about my parents getting back together again isn’t true, sadly. That’s the dream of every child of divorce.”
Apart from her achievements in songwriting, Lewis says that simply realizing she can make music outside the comfort zone of Rilo Kiley was an act of empowerment.
“I now know that I can do it alone,” she admits. “I never thought I could before. I had worked with Blake as my partner for so long, and I knew that he could do it alone, because he makes his own records. But I always thought, if Blake ever decides to leave the band, what would I do? I knew I could sing and play the guitar, but I didn’t know if I could make a record. It’s not that I don’t want to go back and work with Blake, it’s just a different process. And it’s really great to have both options. For once, I was happy, and I didn’t look back.”