In Moonlight, a Silver Lining Emerges

Media Features Moonlight
Share Tweet Submit Pin
In <i>Moonlight</i>, a Silver Lining Emerges

The sound and fury of 2016 has signaled both a lash against and a celebration of inclusion. In cinema, thankfully, it has been the latter.

That is where respite can be found from the accelerating frenzy of the world and U.S. politics. Not to be mistaken, not entirely at least, as an opiate in the Marxian tradition. Film on the contrary has been weaponized in times of political crises. This lull—or indulgence in optimism, if you will—heralding the broadening of film and its social function has been granted by Barry Jenkins’ award-winning independent feature Moonlight. Much buzz has surrounded the mystique of the film and its queer black theme, especially contrasted amidst the current doldrums of Hollywood. Its popularity has already reached a fevered pitch, hailed as the coming-of-age, soon-to-be cultural touchstone film of 2016—and perhaps of this decade. The effusive praise doled out by critics; the film’s commercial achievement; its deeply hyper-stylized cinematic lyricism—by most objective measures, Moonlight has already crossed the threshold into the annals of cinematic history. Deservedly so.

Told in a three-part sequence, Moonlight chronicles a queer young Black man named Chiron in his troubled passage from childhood to adolescence and, finally, to adulthood. His story is set against the realities of material deprivation in an economically depressed Miami and American south—harried by drugs and a punitive carceral regime. Throughout the film, the aesthetics of anguish are rendered in vibrant colors and beckoning visuals of the ocean, of the deep blue that is poetically implicit in every scene and embodied in the flesh.

In this setting, merciless, unrelenting bigotry is perpetrated with impunity against Chiron while many (even his detached mother) turn a blind eye. What opens the film is the child Chiron, alone, running, running with a group of youngsters on his tail verbally assailing him. There is no solace for Chiron, no break from the torment. Lingering shots and periods of profound silence conjure only a nostalgic mournfulness. The film’s score is melancholic. Even Chiron’s teenage years are spent on the realization that everything has become a portent of violent misfortune. Finally, the film’s dénouement suggests a coming-of-age, when adult Chiron reconciles with his past through forgiveness and tacit intimacy.

Along with its rapid accretion of acclaim, the film’s late October limited opening totaled impressive earnings of $402,075. This averages about $100,519 per-location in four theater venues in both Los Angeles and New York City—the highest of any film release in 2016. Later at the American Film Institute, Jenkins even noted that Moonlight’s post-elections sales might indicate underlying shifts in attitudes. The film’s wide release during the November 18th weekend in over 650 theaters accrued $1,488,740 to its box office returns, which raised the film’s overall theatrical earnings ranking to 11th. But why would the box office returns have increased after this particular U.S. election? As of February 1st, 2017, the total earnings reached $18,246,283, while its starting production budget was a mere $5 million. These commercial aspects, combined with the effects of political movements made it clear that the film bears kinship with the social milieu into which it was released.

There was Barack Obama’s presidency. The movement for black lives. The enshrinement of marriage equality in law. And yet, paradoxically, this year alone has witnessed heightened social polarization reaching its logical conclusions. The recurrence of police killings of black people in the United States. The carnage at Aleppo in Syria. The Pulse massacre in Orlando, Florida. Could the surge in Moonlight’s ticket sales, then, be argued to parallel the surge of protesters into the streets affirming lives and values that seem doomed or under assault?

Moonlight comes at this historical moment, at a time that many critics and scholars have designated as the new “black renaissance,” in which the popularity of, say, Donald Glover’s Atlanta and Lee Daniels’ Empire—with its gay lead character, Jamal, (played by openly gay Jussie Smollet) among other shows—has been met with equal social impact. Meanwhile, BAFTA, the British Academy of Film and Television Arts, has moved towards redressing representational disparities. It too emerges out of the public firestorm that came to be known earlier this year as #Oscarssowhite—the Twitter quip which was subsequently affirmed by a more comprehensive report which exposed an epidemic of invisibility for minorities in the entertainment industry. As counterpart to BAFTA in the UK, the Oscars has already begun diversifying its membership roster—which to this day remains a “closely guarded secret.” How the composition of that roster will change is yet to be seen.

The measure of the industry’s progress will be in accountability, to ensure that the industry’s stance, as well as what it purports to do and how it aims to do so, is not flippant. Tokenization would be egregious—the notion that inclusion alone, and its semantics of representational politics, can accrete any concrete change to such an elusive industry is ludicrous.

Not enough can be said about the phenomenon of Moonlight in this era of Black renaissance. A story about sexual non-normativity, yet the narrative’s notable feature is precisely that it eschews mention of any homosexual identity. A story about same-sex love, yet pondering an ambiguous romance, in which sex acts may be absent. It instead offers a romance far more profound beyond the realm of the spoken…. a nuanced cinematic depiction of black queer existence. A story conceived and forged through intimacy, endurance and pain. A majority-Black production played by a virtuoso cast, including Naomie Harris, Mahershala Ali (both now nominated for Best Supporting Actor), Janelle Monáe, Trevante Rhodes, and André Holland, as well as screenwriter Tarell McCraney, a MacArthur genius fellow.

Moonlight currently enjoys eight Oscar nominations, vying for Best Picture—with Jenkins nominated for Best Director and Best Adapted Screenplay (the first black filmmaker to contend for all three awards). But this isn’t a first for Moonlight’s financier, A24, a rather obscure production company founded by two indie-cinema executives back in 2012.

Moonlight reminds us that at the edges of contemporary industrialized Hollywood filmmaking there is no shortage of talent nor of excellence. Indeed, in moonlight or Moonlight, a coming formidable force shimmers into view, brilliantly silhouetted.

Recently in Media
More from Moonlight