78 of the Best Porters (Under 8% ABV), Blind-Tasted and Ranked

Drink Lists Best Porters
Share Tweet Submit Pin
78 of the Best Porters (Under 8% ABV), Blind-Tasted and Ranked

There are few beer styles with deeper roots in the American craft beer movement than porter. Present from the very beginning of this country’s beer renaissance—Anchor has been producing Anchor Porter since 1972, if you can believe that—it has been a bellwether of its times. In its earlier days, porter reflected the English beer style of its inspiration. As time passed, it was Americanized in the way of so many other styles—made bigger, bolder and hoppier, blurring the already nebulous distinction between “robust porter” and “American stout.” Like stout, it too was flavored and imperialized. But still, those classic porters hung around as well.

To many, porter (along with brown ale) was a first style used to dip a toe into the foreboding waters of “dark beer,” only to find a new world of delightful flavor. It’s the reason why porter became so widespread and commonplace, especially in the insular world of the Great American Brewpub. If you visited an American brewpub from 1995 to 2010, it feels almost certain that there was a porter on tap at the time, and probably one that was simply labeled as “porter.”

Today though, porter has become a bit more complicated. Although it’s a style still used by many breweries to offer a session-strength dark beer (and avoid confusion, if they already have an imperial stout, as most do), it’s also been treated as a canvas for experimenting with adjuncts and flavorings. As the number of breweries in this country continues to increase, flying past 6,000 in 2017, the race to find and exploit ever “nichier” niches becomes increasingly paramount. Or in other words, not every brewery can just produce a simple “porter,” or none of them would have the market share to succeed.

And thus, a bunch of porter sub-styles have emerged, often after one beer becomes popular and spurs on dozens of imitators. Take “coconut porter,” for instance—industry wide, there’s a fascination with this combination. Likewise with “peanut butter porter,” which can be found at numerous breweries in specific cities such as Huntsville, Alabama, where it’s something of a local fixture. And of course there are so many more: Hoppy porters, coffee porters, vanilla porters, chocolate porters, barrel-aged porters, etc, etc. More than 45 years after Anchor introduced their porter, there are more versions of this style available than ever.

So let’s get tasting, shall we?

A Note on Beer Acquisition

As in most of our blind tastings at Paste, the vast majority of these porters were sent directly to the office by the breweries that choose to participate, with additional beers acquired by us via locally available purchases and the occasional trade. We always do our best to reach out to breweries we’re aware of that make exemplary versions of particular styles, but things always do slip through the cracks. We apologize for a few significant omissions that we couldn’t acquire, either due to seasonality or market shortages. There will never be a “perfect” tasting lineup, much as we continue to try.

Rules and Procedure

- This is a tasting of porters under 8% ABV, largely determined by how the breweries chose to label their products. All beers had to be labeled as “porter,” but no baltic porters were accepted—this style is traditionally a lager rather than an ale, with many examples stronger than 8% ABV. When in doubt, we simply allow a brewery’s marketing to define a beer’s style, and expect them to stick to the designation they’ve chosen.

- All types of adjuncts and flavorings were allowed. The porters could even be barrel-aged, as long as they were under 8% ABV. Porters stronger than this were included in our blind imperial stout tastings.

- There was a limit of two entries per brewery. The beers were separated into daily blind tastings that approximated a sample size of the entire field.

- Tasters included professional beer writers, brewery owners, brewmasters and beer reps. Awesome, Paste-branded glassware is from Spiegelau.

- Beers were judged completely blind by how enjoyable they were as individual experiences and given scores of 1-100, which were then averaged. Entries were judged by how much we enjoyed them for whatever reason, not by how well they fit any kind of preconceived style guidelines. As such, this is not a BJCP-style tasting.

The Field: Porters #78-26

Most of the porters here in The Field were perfectly serviceable, although in general, this is a style that drew some lower average scores. Some of them were simply not assertive enough to rise above the pack in a field that is increasingly dominated by adjunct beers. Others were just bad examples of adjunct-laden porter, sickeningly sweet or overwhelmingly flavored. Those entries were certainly proof that you can’t just dump a bunch of artificial flavoring into a standard porter and bottle the result.

As always, the beers below are simply listed in alphabetical order, and as a result they are not ranked. I repeat: These beers are not ranked.

Asheville Brewing Co. Ninja Porter
Atlantic Brewing Co. Coal Porter
Back East Brewing Co. Porter
Banded Oak Brewing Co. Porter
Big Alice Brewing Co. Sleep Now in the Fire
Bonfire Brewing Tentpole
Boulder Beer Co. Shake Chocolate Porter
Braxton Brewing Co. Blown Gasket
Breckenridge Brewery Vanilla Porter
Breckenridge Brewery Nitro Vanilla Porter
Central Standard Brewing Keef Richards
Central Waters Brewing Co. Mudpuppy Porter
Cobblehaus Brewing Co. 5 O’Clock
Common Roots Brewing Co. Shadow Figures
COOP Ale Works Gran Sport Porter
Crux Fermentation Project PCT Porter
Dogfish Head Straight Forward Porter
Drake’s Black Robusto Porter
DuClaw Brewing Co. Sweet Baby Java
Elevation Beer Co. Little Mo’
Foothills Brewing Co. People’s Porter
Fremont Brewing Co. Proletariat Porter
Funky Buddha Brewery Last Snow
Great Lakes Brewing Co. Edmund Fitzgerald
Green Man Brewery Porter
Henniker Brewing Co. Working Man’s Porter
Highland Brewing Co. Oatmeal Porter
Hoppin’ Frog Infusion A – Coffee Porter
Ill Mannered Brewing Co. Big Donkey Porter
Indeed Brewing Co. Stir Crazy Porter
Little Machine Beer The Gaffer
NoDa Brewing Co. Coco Loco
O’Connor Brewing Co. Winter Pecan Porter
Odell Cutthroat Porter
Perrin Brewing Co. Blonde Porter
Proof Brewing Co. Hello Dolly Ghost Totem
Quest Brewing Co. Smoking Mirror Porter
Reformation Brewery Stark Porter
Rhinegeist Brewery Panther
Rogue Mocha Porter
San Tan Brewing Co. Sex Panther
Second Self Beer Co. Mole Porter
Sly Fox Co. Mudlust Coffee Porter
Southern Brewing Co. Midnight Train
Speakeasy Ales & Lagers Payback Porter
Station 26 Brewing Co. Cherrywood Smoked Porter
Starr Hill Brewery 2 Tone
Swamp Head Brewery Smoke Signal
Track 7 Brewing Burnt Fog Smoked Porter
The Unknown Brewing Co. Tele-Porter
Wasatch Polygamy Porter
Wasatch Nitro Polygamy Porter
Widmer Brothers Steel Bridge Porter

Next: Porters #25-1

Recently in Drink