The Civilization: A New Dawn Board Game Might Be Too Streamlined

Games Reviews Board games
Share Tweet Submit Pin
The <i>Civilization: A New Dawn</i> Board Game Might Be <i>Too</i> Streamlined

If you’ve played videogames at all in the last 30 years, you’ve probably at least come across Sid Meier’s Civilization franchise, which popularized the game genre known as 4X: eXplore, eXpand, eXploit and eXterminate. First released in 1991, the edition that occupied my time for most of the first semester of my junior year at college, it was itself inspired by a 1980 board game of the same name and by the Empire war games of the 1970s, as well as Meier’s own earlier hits SimCity and Railroad Tycoon. The original Civilization began in 4000 BC and had players start out with one primitive village, exploring the area around them to acquire resources, develop technologies (traversing a “tech tree” of prerequisites); building roads, factories, and Wonders of the World; and, of course, beating the hell out of their opponents. It was incredibly addictive, and subsequent editions have gotten more detailed and longer to play, with the latest edition, 2016’s Civilization VI, apparently as addictive as ever.

I’ve largely avoided the game since the third edition because of the time commitment and my tendency to play it to the exclusion of all other activities short of respiration, and didn’t play the 2010 board game adaptation from Fantasy Flight Games because it suggested a minimum required playing time of two hours (which means you’re probably looking at three-plus). FFG has mitigated that concern with the new version of the game, Civilization: A New Dawn, which came out in December. Rather than stripping out most of the rules from its predecessor or the videogame franchise, this takes the theme and the look of the other games and builds a simpler rule set on the same chassis. That has its pros and cons—while this will definitely feel like Civilization to folks who’ve played any of the earlier titles in the series, it might be too bare-bones to scratch that 4X itch.

Civilization: A New Dawn is designed for two to four players and can be finished in about an hour once you get the hang of the rules. The board is variable in size and shape, and includes hexes of five terrain types plus water spaces. Each player starts with one capital city on the board, and will be able to add up to seven more cities over the course of the game. Players explore the board by placing control tokens on hexes adjacent to their cities, and later adjacent to other control tokens as well; these tokens can be unreinforced or reinforced, which matters if they’re attacked by other players or barbarians, neutral units that move around the board in semi-random fashion.

Each player begins the game with the same five Focus cards, which prescribe the actions the player may take; they’re arrayed in a row under a frame that shows the five terrain types under the numbers 1 through 5. On your turn, you choose one of the five actions and execute it, using the number and/or terrain type to fill in certain variables on the card. If the action you choose involves placing control tokens or building a city, you can only place or build on hexes with terrain types matching the one above the Focus card or those to the left (lower in value/difficulty). If you wish to build a Wonder, the number above the card is the base value to build it, to which you’ll have to add resources. If you attack another player, barbarian or neutral city-state, your base attack value is the number above the card. These five cards are all Era I at the start of the game, and you can advance your tech dial or use other bonuses to upgrade them over the course of the game, up to Era IV cards, which are the most powerful. After you use a card, you move it to the left of the queue and move all cards one slot to the right to fill in the open space, a mechanic that’s become much more common in games the last two or three years (Asmodee’s Otys, released earlier this year, has it too).

civ a new dawn game pieces.jpg

There are no roads or routes in Civilization: A New Dawn, but you do have caravans you can send to those neutral city-states or to other players’ cities to collect trade tokens and gain bonus abilities depending on whom you visit. This function becomes rather silly later in the game, as your movement powers grow to the point where using that Focus card is tantamount to collecting a bunch of trade tokens each turn; those tokens go on Focus cards and let you add to the number above the card to make it more powerful, with a max of three per card, so that by game-end we were just discarding tokens we couldn’t even place.

Winning Civilization: A New Dawn requires meeting three victory conditions, which change each game. At the start of the game, you randomly choose three of the five Agenda cards, each of which shows two victory conditions. To win, you must satisfy one of the conditions on each card. Some conditions involve controlling two Wonders of the same color, while others reward exploration (control 15 hexes, place all 8 of your cities) or development (advance your tech dial all the way to 24, its maximum value). With four players, this will be much tighter, as there will only be six Wonders of each color and you might be able to block an opponent from building his/her second one, but with only two players, these victory conditions were kind of easy to achieve.

In the videogames in the series, you obtained resources by working the land—farming, mining, etc.—but in A New Dawn, the resource tokens are on the board to start the game, along with one natural Wonder per player. You gain a resource token by placing a control token on that space, and do the same with a natural Wonder, which produces one of the depicted resource whenever you need it on future turns. Later Focus cards and Wonders you build can also help you gain or exchange resources as well. This is another example of how the game might oversimplify the eXploit part of the 4X construct: Part of the fun of the Civilization videogames was taking virgin territory and making it productive, then linking your cities and upgrading them so you could move stuff around more efficiently. You built your own little empire, and then, once you became strong enough, used it to wage war or to defend yourself against your opponents, while still developing stuff as you fought.

As a result of these streamlined mechanics, Civilization: A New Dawn feels more like a gateway into 4X gaming than a real spiritual successor to the videogame line, and plays a little too much like a solo game. It would be great as a way to introduce younger players to this idea, especially since it plays quickly and has short turns, but I don’t think it will truly satisfy players who, like me, became way too obsessed with building digital kingdoms, naming cities and moving troops around to try to beat opponents or the AI. It does seem perfectly designed for expansions that can allow players to layer on more complexity, however, perhaps by adding to the tech tree or allowing players to start with greater differences between their civilizations than the one bonus action they get to start the base game.

Keith Law is a senior baseball writer for ESPN.com and an analyst on ESPN’s Baseball Tonight. You can read his baseball content at search.espn.go.com/keith-law and his personal blog the dish, covering games, literature, and more, at meadowparty.com/blog.