• BooksEggers Together: The First-Ever Joint Interview with Dave and Toph EggersBy Charles McNairMay 14, 2009
• MusicRadiohead: Pablo Honey, The Bends, OK Computer (reissues)By Mark KempMarch 27, 2009
• MoviesTrue Blood: The Complete First SeasonBy Jonah FlickerMay 19, 2009Rating8.2
• MusicSamantha Crain & the Midnight Shivers: Songs in the NightBy Steve LaBateApril 29, 2009Rating7.8
• MusicChris Darrow: Chris Darrow and Under My Own DisguiseBy Steve LaBateMay 11, 2009Rating4.1
• MusicAkron/Family: Set 'em Wild, Set 'em FreeBy Corey DubrowaMay 5, 2009Rating5.0
• MusicThe Decemberists: The Hazards of LoveBy Josh Jackson, Nick Marino and Kate KieferMarch 17, 2009
• MusicBuddy & Julie Miller Walk the LineBy Geoffrey HimesMay 28, 2009
• MusicVenice is Sinking: AzarBy Brian HoweApril 30, 2009Rating5.2
• MusicBen Harper and Relentless7: White Lies for Dark TimesBy Jeff LevenMay 4, 2009Rating7.0
• MusicMastodon: Crack The Skye By Michael SabaMarch 23, 2009Rating9.0
• BooksEmily St. John Mandel: Last Night in MontrealBy Alexander F. RemingtonJune 1, 2009Rating6.3
• BooksArthur PhillipsBy Montana WojczukMay 13, 2009Rating9.1
• MusicSt. Vincent: ActorBy Rachael MadduxMay 4, 2009Rating7.7
• MusicThe Decemberists on The Decemberists: Seven Outtakes from Paste's May Cover StoryBy Rachael MadduxMay 31, 2009
• MusicMartina McBride: ShineBy Cory AlbertsonMay 4, 2009Rating3.6
• MoviesThe Hold Steady: A Positive Rage By Andy WhitmanApril 8, 2009Rating7.8
• MusicAllen Toussaint: The Bright MississippiBy Nick MarinoApril 29, 2009Rating8.9
• MusicAlasdair Roberts: SpoilsBy Rob O’ConnorMay 6, 2009Rating7.6
• MusicThe Greencards: FascinationBy Stephen M. DeusnerApril 22, 2009Rating7.3