8.8

The Flash: “Pilot”

(Episode 1.01)

TV Reviews The Flash
The Flash: “Pilot”

Making a good pilot is never easy. For one, it necessitates introducing loads of exposition in terms of building the world and establishing central characters—not to mention somehow fitting in a plot that gives a template for what subsequent episodes will look like. Even some of the greatest TV shows of all time (Buffy, Seinfeld, Star Trek: Next Generation, to name a few) can get tripped up by demanding requirements of “the pilot episode.”

Granted, as a spin-off, The Flash has the advantage of being set in a pre-established world, with the character of Barry Allen (Grant Gustin) having been introduced during a two-episode arc in last year’s Arrow. Perhaps because the show’s creators have had so long to mull on this character, the Flash pilot (pardon all subsequent puns) speeds along with an efficiency and confidence that places it in the top-tier of this year’s new TV offerings.

As the episode opens, we are promptly reintroduced to Barry, the Central City-based forensics assistant who traveled to Starling City to help Oliver solve a case (and saved his life in the process). What we didn’t know about Barry is, as with many superheroes, he carries dark familial trauma in his past. As a young boy, Barry watched helplessly as a mysterious lightening formation invaded his living room and killed his mother. Barry’s father, Henry (John Wesley Shipp, a great bit of casting considering he played The Flash in the beloved, yet short-lived 1990 CBS show), was then arrested for his wife’s murder.

After this flashback, the show catches us up to present-day Barry. He now works in the police department under the supervision of father figure Detective Joe West (Jesse L. Martin). Shortly after returning from his encounter with The Arrow (one major set-back for those without knowledge of Arrow, Barry hints at a dramatic encounter that we never see), he watches as the city’s Particle Accelerator experiences a meltdown. In the midst of the chaos, Barry is struck by lightning, and put into a nine-month coma.

Upon awakening, Barry quickly realizes that not only has he gained a killer set of abs, but he now has the ability to run faster than any man alive. With the help of scientists Caitlin Snow (Danielle Panabaker) and Cisco Ramon (Carlos Valdes) as well as Harrison Wells (Tom Cavanagh), the inventor of the disastrous Particle Accelerator who has been left paralyzed by the accident, Barry must realize his potential and emerge as the hero he was destined to become. And it couldn’t have happened at a more perfect time since the city is being terrorized by Clyde Mardon, a criminal who—in the wake of the particle accelerator explosion—now has the ability to control the weather (hello, Weather Wizard).

As I said before, there is much to love in this concise, yet enthralling 45 minutes. Unlike Arrow, a generally fun show often prone to Nolan-esque bouts of dark drama, Flash is perfectly fine with just being fun. Sure, there are moments of legitimate pathos, particular involving Barry’s backstory, but the episode as a whole feels much brighter and jokey than the likes of Arrow, and its brooding cast of characters. Not to say one is better than the other, but it’s nice to have an orange for every apple.

Much of this tone-setting stems from Gustin, who does an exceptional job playing both the lovable, Peter Parker-esque goof, while still being able to convincingly portray the strong-willed hero he later becomes. Upon initial announcement of his casting, I feared that Gustin would not quite have the star power or charisma to carry a show on his own. This pilot promptly blew all my reservations out of the water. He’s that good.

The rest of the cast files in nicely as well. As Barry’s conflicting father figures, both Jesse L. Martin and Tom Cavanagh equip themselves well. And while Cavanagh seemed a tad stilted at times, a subsequent Marvel-esque post-stringer establishes that his character may be more complex than we initially realized.

As Barry’s awkward love interest (considering they’ve grown up together in the same house), Candice Patton is fine as Detective West’s daughter Ira, but one hopes this won’t turn into another Laurel Lance situation whereby the scripts will constantly place in her the damsel-in-distress role. Considering she’s currently dating Eddie Thawne (Rick Cosnett), the new police transfer who shares the same name as Flash nemesis Professor Zoom, things are not looking good for her.

If the pilot experiences any other stumbles, it involves the occasional ham-fisted nature of some of the dialogue. Arrow co-creator Andrew Kreisberg and writer/comic book extraordinaire Geoff Johns are both credited for the pilot and, altogether, they do a fantastic job at streamlining the fun parts of the origin story. In fact, many fans of Johns’ Flash run will be happy to see elements of his comic book writing reflected here. Nevertheless, like Arrow, The Flash sometimes tends to treat its themes as monologues to be shouted from the rooftop. This proves to be somewhat literal as, about two-thirds into the episode, Barry travels to Starling City for a heart-to-heart with Oliver. And while I understand why this scene is here—it represents the original, flagship show giving its goodwill to the spin-off—the exchange does feel like something that might have worked better in a comic book bubble than coming out of an actor’s mouth. “I don’t think that bolt of lightning struck you, Barry, I think it choose you,” Oliver says in one of the scene’s more on-the-nose bits of dialogue.

Ultimately, however, these are fairly small nitpicks in the broad scheme of things. At this point, I realize I’ve probably employed a drastic overuse of the word “fun” in this recap, but—honestly—it’s hard not to. With only a few bumps here and there, The Flash truly succeeds at adapting the madcap pacing and heightened mania of its funny books origins into an exceptionally entertaining hour of TV.

It’s official—I have a new favorite TV show.

Mark Rozeman is a Los Angeles-based freelance writer and regular contributor to Paste. You can follow him on Twitter.

Share Tweet Submit Pin