A Folky Feast
By Kate Kiefer
Slim Pickins
By Andy Whitman
Langhorne Slim’s shtick—the ramblin’ folkie troubadour, with accompanying nasal yelp and requisite weather-beaten cap—is a tough act to sell. You’re only competing with Woody Guthrie and the young Bob Dylan. The songs had better be good. On his third full album, Slim adds some pop sheen to the expected folkie raggedness, but Woody can rest easy, and Bob doesn’t need to think twice. These are mediocre, and sometimes painfully inept, approximations of classic lovelorn folk tunes. At a short 38 minutes, the times aren’t changin’ fast enough.
On “Land Of Dreams,” Slim opines, “Everyone has got a dream, you know what I mean / Everyone wants to see what they’ve never seen.” Hallmark Cards, Inc. would agree. On the dour ballad “Sunday by the Sea,” he drops this pearl of wisdom: “What’s happened has happened, what will be we’ll see.” Doris Day would be proud. And on the lugubrious, overwrought title track, Slim sings, “Whether I’m right, whether I’m wrong / Time it goes by, life it goes on.” Yep. That just about covers it. Slim’s in love, and then out of love, and he doesn’t have an original thing to say about it.

It looks as though second reviewer was so turned off by Langhorne's alleged "schtick" that he failed to give this new album it's fair shake.
If album covers are worth anything, doesn't it seem like this album is posited as Langhorne's move away from schtick and toward substance? (here we see an image of Langhorne without his 'requisite' dome piece--making it, well, no longer requisite, no?)
Also, Hallmark cards don't have the benefit of a beautifully complex voice with which to transmit their ostensibly trite expressions. Why not hone in on what the voice embeds within the words?
Whatever, this album is fantastic. Slim's best yet.
I have to agree, having just heard a bunch of his songs, the second review falls victim to what apparently is the universal truth for the current artistic world. That it must be original in everyday or it's just not worth it, groundbreaking or nothing. But music isn't just the worlds, it isn't just the playing, it isn't just the voice, it's all of it meshing together. And in this case it makes for very enjoyable music.