Music geeks create something utterly original
Sufjan Stevens propped open the door to the marching-band practice room earlier this decade, and since then several of his band-camp compatriots have strutted out onto the wider field of popular music. Chicago septet Anathallo is at the head of this geeky class, and the band upholds its reputation on sophomore album Canopy Glow.
Like its predecessor, 2006’s Floating Worldgorgeous mashup that splits the difference between Animal Collective,
the Salvation Army band and the neighborhood glee club. It’s the same
approach Stevens has employed so masterfully on albums such as
Illinois, but there are some important differences. First, everybody
sings, and although guitarist/pianist Matt Joynt and autoharp player
Erica Froman handle the lion’s share of the vocals, there’s a marked
emphasis on choral harmony that’s mostly absent from Stevens’ albums.
Second, almost everybody bangs or pulls on something—bass drums,
glockenspiels, Velcro, balloons—and there’s a primal rhythmic focus
here that nicely offsets the egghead sensibilities. I’d call it an
everything-but-the-kitchen-sink approach, but the members of Anathallo
are probably inclined to bang on the kitchen sink, too.
All of which would make for an idiosyncratic but disposable effort if
the songs weren’t so well constructed. “The River” is typical: Starting
with pensive piano, the song builds layer upon layer, first adding
contrapuntal vocals from Froman, then a trumpet, then a cello and
percussion before building to a cascading, swirling climax of strings
and horns and multi-layered vocals. It is sweeping, symphonic and
The lyrics are quirky and mystical (one song ruminates on a Cool Whip
bowl used as a baptismal font); the song structures are endlessly
inventive, constantly subverting standard verse/chorus/verse
construction. And it’s all elevated by a transparent focus on beauty
and wonder. This is a marching band that’s veered way out of formation,
and is making utterly original music.
Listen to Anathallo's "The River" from Canopy Glow on the Anticon site here.