8.6

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Is a Gorgeous, Welcome Return to Middle-Earth

TV Reviews The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
Share Tweet Submit Pin
<i>The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power</i> Is a Gorgeous, Welcome Return to Middle-Earth

It’s hard to overstate the cultural impact of author J.R.R. Tolkien, whose The Lord of the Rings trilogy—along with The Hobbit, The Silmarillion, various appendices, ancillary notes, and assorted scribbles centered on his world of Middle Earth—essentially came to define the idea of epic fantasy fiction. Though its first volume, The Fellowship of the Ring, was initially published in 1954, the impact of the trilogy has been keenly felt throughout the decades that have followed, in media ranging from books and music to feature films and videogames. And, of course, we’re all familiar with Peter Jackson’s Oscar-winning series of films, which basically turned even the most casual of fantasy nerds into deep lore experts on hobbits and orcs. (Though I think we can all agree that the actual The Hobbit films should really have just been a single movie.)

Given all that, perhaps it was always inevitable that a Lord of the Rings-adjacent series would come to television one day. After all, it’s one of the last great fantasy franchises that still doesn’t have a television counterpart (I mean, heck, even Neil Gaiman’s The Sandman finally made it to Netflix earlier this year) and it’s got the kind of built-in name recognition that even the savviest of marketing campaigns can’t create. But could anything live up to what we’ve seen before? After all, if you come at the king—or The Return of the King, in this case—you best not miss.

Prime Video’s The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power doesn’t miss. Or, at least, it doesn’t in the first two episodes that critics were given to review (out of a total of eight). Yes, there’s still a not insignificant chance that the series’ rich, laboriously slow build will ultimately turn out to be a road to nowhere or that it will stray too far from Tolkien’s original story. (Much of this show is only loosely based on his work at the best of times.) But in just two episodes, The Rings of Power has made me a believer, enough that I’ll be very happy to see this road go (ever on and) on for several more seasons to come.

Set during the Second Age, The Rings of Power takes place thousands of years before the events of Jackson’s movies, but its primary narrative will feel fairly familiar regardless. And part of the reason for that is it’s essentially the story that Cate Blanchett’s Galadriel tells via voiceover at the start of those films. (That Galadriel herself—here played by a luminous Morfydd Clark—is one of the main characters of this series is the sort of symmetry I think Tolkien himself would have appreciated.) As the title implies, The Rings of Power is technically about the Dark Lord Sauron’s rise and the forging of the great rings meant to seduce Middle Earth to his whims, but it’s the intimate, personal nature of the way the show chooses to tell that story that will stick with you well after the episode credits roll.

Don’t get me wrong, The Rings of Power is positively massive in scope, easily dwarfing any expectations most viewers had for it, and boasting the sort of visuals that go a long way to justifying that hefty billion-dollar price tag we’ve all read so many dire industry forecasts about. And the show has an ambitious story to match its visuals, deftly weaving together at least half a dozen major plots and twice that many main characters across a rich and fully lived-in landscape, one that spans from the northernmost wastes of Forodwaith to the Southlands that will one day be called by the much darker name of Mordor.

Such is the power of Tolkien’s worldbuilding—and the cultural penetration of Jackson’s movies—that the setting of The Rings of Power feels deeply familiar from the show’s opening scenes, despite the fact that many viewers will likely have never heard of any of these places before. Because while Rivendell may not exist in this story just yet, the Elvish city of Lindon boasts a similar natural and sweeping beauty. And though we may only have seen Khazad-dum when it had already become the black pit of Moria, somehow that only makes the visual impact of the intricate city of the dwarves more impressive. And it is extremely impressive.

More importantly, however, the series just feels right. Grand in scale but intimate in its story, this is a series that’s as grounded in relationships as it is prophecy, as concerned with what the threat of Sauron means to the everyday lives of the races of Middle Earth as it is the larger battle of good and evil written across ages. The series’ first two episodes do a good job of introducing us to a variety of characters well beyond the familiar Galadriel and a much younger Elrond (Robert Aramayo), including dwarf prince Durin IV (Owain Arthur), his wife Disa (Sophia Nomvete), a human healer named Bronwyn (Nazanin Boniadi), and the silvan elf soldier Arondir (Ismael Cruz Córdova) who has spent decades as part of the garrison keeping watch over the Southlands. Perhaps the most interesting initial new face is the harfoot Elanor “Nori” Brandyfoot (Markella Kavenagh), a nomadic ancestor to The Hobbits who will one day come to settle in the Shire and whose distinctly Baggins-esque longing for adventure is plain from her first moments on screen.

Some Tolkien enthusiasts will likely grumble about the show’s decision to play a bit fast and loose with what we know of Galadriel’s origin story—though her decision to remain in Middle Earth is the same, the reasons behind it are wildly different and much more personal—but the Elvish leader is a natural choice to center this series around. Familiar yet fiery, her presence offers a welcome, necessary female perspective that, let’s be honest, this franchise has often struggled to include. In fact, one of the best things about The Rings of Power is how many female characters are in it and how integral they are to the story the show is telling. (As someone who imprinted on Eowyn of Rohan at a very early age, it’s nice to have more options, is all I’m saying.)

It’s true, the pace of The Rings of Power’s first two episodes is slow and deliberate, and the show has to work to balance its screentime amongst many seemingly disconnected plotlines. But it’s clear that the show feels confident enough in the story it’s telling to allow its audience the necessary time to get to know its characters and their various goals and passions, before launching into the potentially world-ending stakes in their future. I’m looking forward to finding out if that confidence is truly warranted, but this is the sort of beginning that certainly makes me want to believe in magic.

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power premieres Friday, September 2nd on Amazon Prime Video.



Lacy Baugher Milas is the Books Editor at Paste Magazine, but loves nerding out about all sorts of pop culture. You can find her on Twitter @LacyMB.

For all the latest TV news, reviews, lists and features, follow @Paste_TV.