Editor’s Note: This review originally published on October 30th 2018, when CBS All Access first premiered the series. Cancelled after two seasons, The CW will now air this anthology starting July 28th, 2020. As such, we’ve pulled Amy Amatangelo’s initial review out from the vault to remind us what it’s all about!
I can remember going to see Scream when it first premiered and being so nervous. Horror movies are rated not for me, but everyone I knew was talking about Scream and I didn’t want to be the wimp who wouldn’t go.
Of course, I was pleasantly surprised, as it turns out that Kevin Williamson makes horror I can tolerate—the kind where he upends tropes, adds a dash of humor, and doesn’t wallow in unnecessary gore. In his new series Tell Me a Story, Williamson mines fairy tales for fodder. And, let’s be honest, with wolves dressed up like grandmothers and the fixation on dead parents, it’s not like fairy tales were a laugh riot to begin with.
Here, Williamson weaves stories loosely inspired by The Three Little Pigs, Hansel and Gretel and Little Red Riding Hood to tell a story of the horror of living in the modern era. As Williamson well knows, the world is scary enough. With the horrendous events of the past week, we don’t need a TV show to tell us what an awful place it can be.
Beth (Spencer Grammer) worries about bringing a baby into the world filled with such violence. “I don’t think there will ever be a time for children,” she tells her fiancé, Jordan (James Wolk). In the pilot, Jordan and Beth are the most compelling. And they firmly set the story in Trump’s America. “Can we please not ruin another dinner by talking about Trump?” Jordan asks.
For some storylines, the loose reference to the source material is more overt. Tim (Sam Jaeger) has moved across the country with his daughter, Kayla (Danielle Campbell), to live with his mother, Colleen (Kim Cattrall—as a grandmother!). Still reeling from the death of her mother (fairy tales!), Kayla wants nothing to do with her father and spurns her grandmother’s offer of a red raincoat. She sneaks out of the house to go to a club and meets Nick (Billy Magnussen.) (A wolf in sheep’s clothing, perhaps?) Kaya has a tattoo of a wolf, because the lone wolf is a “symbol of power and perseverance.”
For others, the series has yet to reveal the way it will pay full homage to the stories that inspired it. Hannah (Dania Ramirez) is struggling to forget her past, while Eddie (Paul Wesley) and his brother, Mitch (Michael Raymond-James), are finding less than respectable ways to make money. When Hannah’s brother, Gabe (Davi Santos), gets into trouble, he calls her because he doesn’t know what to do. “Leave me out of it! You could have left me out of it!” Hannah screams.
The cast is for TV fans. In addition to Cattrall, the series pulls mainstays from The Vampire Diaries, Parenthood and Once Upon a Time. While watching, you can play a fun game of “Where have I seen them before?” Oh look, there’s the dad from Netflix’s One Day at a Time. Since it drove me crazy while watching, I’ll save you the trouble and tell you Magnussen was Kato Kaelin in The People v. O.J. Simpson: American Crime Story.
As noted above, the CW will now be airing the first two seasons of this anthology during the COVID-19 production shutdowns starting Tuesday, July 28th at 9 p.m.
For all the latest TV news, reviews, lists and features, follow @Paste_TV.
Amy Amatangelo, the TV Gal®, is a Boston-based freelance writer, a member of the Television Critics Association and the Assistant TV Editor for Paste. She wasn’t allowed to watch much TV as a child and now her parents have to live with this as her career. You can follow her on Twitter (@AmyTVGal) or her blog .