Conan the Barbarian at 40: Remembering the Movie that Made Arnold Schwarzenegger

While Schwarzenegger’s first feature was 1970’s Hercules in New York, where he was credited as “Arnold Strong ‘Mr. Universe’” and his voice had to be recorded over, he later won a Golden Globe for New Star for 1976’s Stay Hungry before appearing in Pumping Iron. A second bodybuilding documentary, The Comeback was released in 1980 after his surprise reentry into the Mr. Olympia pageant. But Conan the Barbarian was Arnold’s breakout role because of the magnetism of his central performance. He was written and directed to act almost as if he were a man gone feral whose penchant for violence enticed his masters to educate him and then finally free him. Arnold played every bit convincingly, from the effective warrior to the desperate runaway, from the sneaking thief to the man caught drunk partying; from lout to warrior, ever single-minded in his vengeance, neither humorless nor dull, eloquent in his declarations and oaths behind his thick Styrian accent. Audiences and studios saw this and thought: “We need more!” It led to the sequel Conan the Destroyer coming just a few months before his iconic antagonistic role as The Terminator in 1984. In 1985, he teamed-up with Conan the Destroyer director Richard Fleischer for Red Sonja as a supporting character (alongside Conan’s Sandahl Bergman) to Brigitte Nielsen’s heroine.

Propelled by the success of Conan, Schwarzenegger averaged a new film nearly every year. In 1985’s Commando and 1987’s Predator, he played government agents in the jungle, appearing alongside Carl Weathers in Predator and Bill Duke in both films. Jesse “The Body” Ventura appeared alongside Schwarzenegger in The Running Man and Predator in the same year. Toward the end of the 1980s and into the 1990s, Schwarzenegger started his comedic successes with 1988’s Red Heat (a buddy cop film co-starring Jim Belushi) and Twins (with Danny DeVito) before 1990’s Kindergarten Cop. Yet he didn’t fully cede his claim as a bankable action star, starring in Paul Verhoeven’s Total Recall released that same year, followed by Terminator 2: Judgment Day in 1991. These were followed by 1993’s Last Action Hero, a fantasy-action satire where he plays multiple roles—including himself and a parody of the gun-toting character archetype he had begun to define after stepping away from the sword-and-sorcery genre. Schwarzenegger teamed up with DeVito again in 1994’s Junior, where he plays a cisgender man that gets pregnant, and it was sort of all downhill from there. None of his films have been appointment viewing since. Four Terminator sequels were released between 2003 and 2019, with Schwarzenegger appearing in all but one, cast in two roles in the most recent film.

If actors were ever set in this mold, they’re not anymore. As a musclebound hero, Arnold is of a kind with Rocky and Rambo star Sylvester Stallone (and whoever else Stallone casts in The Expendables franchise), but his acting ability has been underrated because of his iconic accent. Conan, the T-800 Terminator, Doug Quaid (Total Recall) and Harry Tasker (True Lies) are distinct characters. How many well-remembered comedies was Stallone in? Schwarzenegger has Twins, Kindergarten Cop, The Last Action Hero and True Lies. Aquaman is a much better movie than Batman & Robin, but Schwarzenegger’s Mr. Freeze is far more memorable than Dolph Lundgren’s King Nereus.

Perhaps Stallone’s (increasingly critically panned) Expendables franchise is instructive because of the variety of action-star archetypes it casts while exemplifying an over-the-top throwback style. On the one hand there’s the giant athlete-turned-actor in Schwarzenegger, his contemporary Lundgren and their latter-day successors Terry Crews (NFL) and Randy Couture (UFC). In age and size, Steve Austin is somewhere on that spectrum, while Jet Li is a legendary martial artist-filmmaker. Bruce Willis is a whole other sort; he’s similarly aged into a nostalgic action space, but he wasn’t ever their type of action hero. His breakout role in Die Hard was not a glamorous, well-oiled killing machine but a hard-scrabble cop improvising in a bad situation, remembered for outwitting terrorist bank robbers, barefoot and bleeding. That persona would follow him through sequels and into the flamboyant space opera The Fifth Element.

As Schwarzenegger has aged out of his acting prime, the most obvious comparison for the past two decades has been Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson, another musclebound former athlete. While Stallone handed the Rocky torch to Michael B. Jordan through the Creed movies, I thought The Rock fit Schwarzenegger’s archetype. Johnson has the charisma; the charm; the bulging, defined, musculature that definitely has nothing to do with steroids. While he’s a consistent international box office draw, he lacks a truly iconic performance carried on his shoulders, the kind of movie you want to show your younger family members and friends as you age. I have an uncle that used to quote Conan the Barbarian. The entire world quotes the first and second Terminator movies, and Predator also has its famous lines and memeable moments.

While seeing The Rock on screen brings me joy, the closest thing to a memorable quote is the frequent utterance of “sumbitch” in Fast Five. The Scorpion King is not quoted. Hercules is not remembered. And none of this is because The Rock himself is not compelling. Johnson commands a screen and is often funny in addition to being a handsome mountain of muscle, but his films (such as Hobbs & Shaw) ask him to take a dive less than his wrestling did because, as his fame and popularity have increased, he’s constructed his image in a way that basically prohibits losing fights.

On the other hand, Schwarzenegger took licks. He gets crucified in Conan the Barbarian, he’s harried through the jungle in Commando and Predator, and he was constantly on the run, as in Raw Deal, The Running Man and The 6th Day. Short of The Rock, Arnold Schwarzenegger doesn’t have a clear successor—his son Patrick was good in Daniel Isn’t Real, but he’s hardly a hulking action star. His son-in-law Chris Pratt doesn’t have his charm. Arnold Schwarzenegger is one of a kind.

Among the other action stars of the 1980s, those he co-starred with in Commando or Predator, it might have been hard to predict Arnold’s longevity or singularity. Schwarzenegger got a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame in 1987, before becoming Chairman of the President’s Council on Physical Health and Fitness from 1990-1993, and California’s governor from 2003-2011. None of his other co-stars reached Arnold’s level of iconic status, though Jesse Ventura did win an upset bid to become governor of Minnesota. The determination and willpower that defined Conan matched Schwarzenegger’s own drive and, while he’s often spoken about the mentors that enabled his opportunities, he’s an easy man to build a myth around. Conan the Barbarian stands out among the continuum of 1980s fantasy adventure movies because of this incredible legacy. The visually distinct execution of a simple plot showed a style of fantasy adventure separate from its contemporaries and predecessors, setting Schwarzenegger on a path to become the most successful action star of his generation. Conan enabled an Austrian bodybuilder to become a global film icon.

Kevin Fox, Jr. is a freelance writer, editor, and critic. He is a former Paste intern with an MA in history, who loves videogames, film, TV, and sports, and dreams of liberation. He can be found on Twitter @kevinfoxjr.