Josh Server (1994-2000)
Then: Took an particularly sensitive turn as the auricularly over-endowed Ear Boy.
Now: Was the only cast member to stay on for the show’s entire first run, but aside from a few a few brief appearances on other Nickelodeon shows— Drake & Josh, Ned’s Declassified School Survival Guide (watch us listing those like we have any idea what they are)—he hasn’t done very much since. And no one is sadder about that than the webmaster of this Angelfire fan page.
Amanda Bynes (1996-2000)
Then: Put a manic pubescent spin on Ann Landers with “Ask Ashley.”
Now: Before she announced her retirement via Twitter last week, Bynes had perhaps the most successful post-show run of any All That cast member, including her own spin-off series (The Amanda Show, which ran on Nickelodeon from 1999 to 2002), a lead role in the WB series What I Like About You and a string of leads in Hollywood films—What A Girl Wants, She’s The Man and Hairspray among them. Assuming her retirement sticks, Bynes’ last role will be in this fall’s Easy A.