It Still Stings: The CW’s Rush to Judgment With Nikita

It Still Stings: The CW’s Rush to Judgment With Nikita
Introducing Endless Mode: A New Games & Anime Site from Paste

For four seasons, The CW’s Nikita brought action, surprising brutality, and a beautiful vulnerability to the screen with each thrilling and heart-stopping mission the characters became entangled in. Based on the French film La Femme Nikita, the series begins with the so-called killer with a conscience, Nikita Mears (Maggie Q), putting her years-long plan in motion to bring down the covert, government-funded organization Division, which faked her execution seven years prior and subsequently groomed her into one of the world’s deadliest assassins. Unfortunately, Nikita never quite got the attention it deserved for its high-quality storytelling and rich character work, and was ultimately cancelled after a shortened fourth and final season consisting of just six episodes. Although Nikita still managed to pull off a great ending given the circumstances, this too-tight episode count didn’t allow for proper closure, as there was simply too much story to tackle.

In the CW’s adaptation, the show dives much deeper into the world of its titular (anti-)heroine and her complex motivations than a feature film could ever hope to provide. Here, the journey begins years after Nikita’s escape from Division, at a time when she probably could have remained in the shadows for the rest of her life, but purposefully returns seeking vengeance and justice. Why? Firstly, Division turned her into a killer, a fact which weighs on her every day. Second, those in charge killed her fiancé, a civilian, because she had gotten too close to him, and they realized her loyalty had become compromised. But, most importantly, because the organization strayed far from its original purpose to be the government’s secret, untraceable weapon.  still conducts the occasional government-sanctioned operation, but most of its new missions are assassinations paid for by anyone with enough cash to line the pockets of its leader, Percy (Xander Berkeley). 

Despite the odds being stacked against her, facing off against a group with hundreds of trained operatives and millions at its disposal, Nikita and, eventually, her team—Alex (Lyndsy Fonseca), Michael (Shane West), and Birkhoff (Aaron Stanford), to name a few—prove their impeccable skills and fierce commitment repeatedly, sometimes only narrowly escaping with their lives. The well-written story takes plenty of twists and turns along the way, including Nikita and her team taking charge of Division during the show’s third season. It’s an unexpected but necessary development—though the group hated the place, staying and hunting down rogue operatives is the only option. (Otherwise, the President will kill every existing operative and wipe Division off the map entirely.) But the season’s most shocking twist occurs when Nikita’s nemesis (and former mentor), Amanda (Melinda Clarke) uses science-fiction-esque technology from a new shadowy group known as The Shop to frame Nikita for the murder of the President in the Season 3 finale. 

After this cliffhanger was filmed, The CW canceled Nikita, giving the series only six more episodes to wrap up not one, but three enormous plotlines (including finally putting a stop to Amanda). How could even one of those be wrapped up with a satisfying conclusion in such a meager timeframe? Of course, the fact that the show got six episodes to conclude its story is a blessing and better than total cancellation, especially in the wake of such a game-changing cliffhanger. But that doesn’t mitigate the ways that The CW essentially set Nikita up for failure. 

Instead of allowing the show time to build toward a proper conclusion and bring all ongoing stories to a close, the final season is forced to rush things along and, frankly, becomes quite messy. If not for the exceptional writing showcased throughout the series, the final season would’ve likely been a total loss. Not many shows could handle the pressure, but Nikita delivers a final arc that works fairly well and is a decent and believable conclusion, despite moving at breakneck speed. Still, there was much more that needed to be done along the way to the destination. 

The series finale, aptly and cheekily entitled “Canceled,” brings Nikita’s entire arc to a generally satisfying close. However, it doesn’t do much justice to Michael or Birkhoff as individuals, and series co-lead Alex is all but fed to the wolves. After having her mind altered by Amanda and losing her boyfriend Sean (Dillon Casey) near the end of the third season, Alex finally reclaimed her identity as the Udinov heiress and emerged from the shadows herself. But there was no possible way to bring Alex’s story to a rewarding end in such a measly amount of time. Likewise, fan-favorite Owen (Devon Sawa) basically became an entirely new and different character named Sam just a few episodes prior, turning against his friends. This direction might’ve worked if there were more time to explore the ramifications of this switch, but that wasn’t the case, and the twist ultimately remains one of the weakest and least satisfying aspects of the entire show.

Furthermore, the series had only just begun to delve into Amanda’s psyche and the torture she experienced as a child while forced to endure her father’s unsuccessful experiments. We had not learned nearly enough about her, as she was somewhat sidelined for the first two seasons because Percy was the Big Bad. Simply put, there was so much more to learn about the character, who was a genuinely fascinating and terrifying villain. While a shortened final season is a much better end for Nikita than an abrupt cancellation would have been, it still stings that the show was cut short so suddenly and without time to fully conclude the story it was so clearly building toward. Six episodes were simply not enough. 

When it premiered in 2010, Nikita was unlike anything else on The CW. It joined the ranks of some of the network’s most notable shows: Gossip Girl, The Vampire Diaries, and Supernatural. Aside from weekly procedural-style missions, like Supernatural’s monster du jour, it didn’t have much in common with its sister programs. Admittedly, this made it an odd choice, leaving it feeling like an outlier, and most likely contributed to it never garnering the attention it deserved from both the audience and the network. Nonetheless, more than a decade later, Nikita remains a brilliant and entertaining watch and is still definitively one of the best shows to come from The CW. But it’s difficult not to imagine how much better the ending could have been if the curtains had been gradually pulled to a close with a full-season order.


Jay Snow is a freelance writer and TV critic. For more of his thoughts on television and to find his other work, follow him on Bluesky: @snowyjay.

For all the latest TV news, reviews, lists, and features, follow @Paste_TV.

 
Join the discussion...