Cartooning Legend Bernard Krigstein’s Career Foreshadowed a Lethargic Comics Industry
Comics Features
The common influence between such benchmark comics as Sin City, Maus and Ghost World, Bernard Krigstein is your favorite artist’s favorite artist. Though his name is little-known to the average reader, he pushed the boundaries of what comics could be in their Golden Age, and his fine-art intentions have drawn comparisons to the literary ambitions of V For Vendetta and Watchmen writer Alan Moore. He also would have been 97 this week. In the face of censorship legislation, Krigstein was forced out of the industry at the height of his power, relegated to teaching high school art classes for the last decades of his life. While his abrasive attitude was no doubt a contributing factor in this development, his short-lived career still speaks to a recurrent problem in the comics industry, one as topical today as it’s ever been.
Even at the dawn of sequential art, Krigstein faced a harsh reality that’s remained consistent to today: the comics industry abhors change. This conservatism has taken various forms throughout the decades—the ‘50s endured the restrictive, short-sighted psychology of Fredric Wertham. The fight continues today as the medium faces hurdles to diversify its creators beyond a white, heteronormative male foundation. Like other media, the comics industry has rarely accepted those voices who sought to innovate within its panels—Krigstein is a testament to that unfortunate legacy.
The Matster Race by Bernard Krigstein
Born in 1919, Krigstein spent the early days of his career working on short stories like “The Monkey’s Circle!” and “Eugene Vidocq…First Great Detective.” He signed his work as “B.B. Krig.,” recalling a nickname he picked up in the army: “ballbuster.” According to Maus creator Art Spiegelman, Krigstein was a formally educated painter, but he pursued comics to support himself. Realizing the potential of the form, he devoted his time and energy to expanding its boundaries.
Krigstein’s career was rocky; work was scarce and he bounced around from publisher to publisher, often saddled with assignments that didn’t allow him to fully explore the extent of his skills. Recounting his work for superhero publisher Fawcett in the late ‘40s, the artist described his output as “hackwork of the purest distillation,” and refused to even sign his issues. But he continued to publish at a variety of magazines—even contributing “Drummer of War” to DC’s Our Army at War anthology. Most of his works, however, were short-lived and are now long forgotten, though he did contribute to MAD during its heyday.
Krigstein would often balk at deadlines, slowing down his process by inking his pencils instead of handing them off to another artist. He once unsuccessfully tried to unionize comic book artists—a movement editors and publishers tend to frown upon. He eventually fell in with EC, a company most famous for its lascivious horror comics like Tales from the Crypt, where his ambition and singular style were encouraged. The publisher even allowed him to expand his opus, “Master Race,” from six to eight pages.
Running in the first issue of EC’s new suspense thriller anthology, Impact, “Master Race” tells the story of Carl Reissman, a Nazi who works in a concentration camp only to escape to America and anonymity. Today, the topic of Nazis and Nazism is common fodder for pop-culture, but in 1955, Krigstein was touching on something recent and controversial. Released the same year as “Master Race,” Alain Resnais’ documentary Night and Fog dealt with identical subject matter, “an almost unheard-of theme in Western mass media.” The film was so controversial that West Germany convinced France to pull it from the Cannes Film Festival.
The Matster Race by Bernard Krigstein
In “Master Race,” a former prisoner recognizes Reissman on a subway car and the expatriate tries to escape, falling to his death beneath the train. The story is brief and lurid, but at the time, it tackled subject matter—The Holocaust—that hadn’t often been touched on in popular media. More importantly, Krigstein did it with a shocking amount of psychological depth and ambiguity. Employing smart storytelling conceits, he conceals the identity of his protagonist—a Nazi—for the first few pages. Like all the best comics, the art is the primary storytelling apparatus, and that visual writing reaches its zenith in a sequence where Krigstein slows down time to detail every little moment of Reissman slipping off the subway platform.
“Master Race” represents everything that comics could possibly be: the integration of text and image; the exploration of time; the nuanced interplay between inks and color. Some comics play sublimely with the interaction between text and image, colors and time. But “Master Race” plays with them all at once, and did so before formalists like David Mazzucchelli and Chris Ware made their names mastering the concept.
From Eddie Campbell to Ron Wimberly, Krigstein’s influence transcends generations, and his fingerprints remain on innumerable comics and films. Unfortunately for the auteur, his masterpiece was published just after the 1954 Senate hearings on juvenile delinquency that lead to the Comics Code Authority, the industry’s self-regulating body that forbade sex, drugs, violence and zombies, among other “challenging” concepts. In Art Spiegelman’s words, the “comics industry evaporated around [Krigstein]”. In the furor of the hearings and the distribution shake-up it caused, almost no one saw Impact #1. Krigstein futilely tried to adapt War and Peace for comics, but by 1963 he had quit the medium for a 20-year teaching stint at the High School of Art and Design in New York.
Only at the tail end of his career was Krigstein able to find “an environment that was receptive to his interests,” and his inability to find a niche within comics speaks to the industry’s longform resistance to change. “All of his efforts,” writes comics artist and historian Santiago Garcia, “were moderated by the inherent limitations of the business […] and the scripts never ceased to be basic and pitched at an adolescent…readership,” a readership that the Comics Code Authority stipulated could not be exposed to nudity, sex, drugs, profanity or even criticism of public officials.
The Matster Race by Bernard Krigstein
The market never knew what to make of Krigstein’s nuanced and complex work, and it often experienced low sales. And while comics has made incredible progress in the intervening 65 years, it all came slow and hard-fought. The most lasting change, to this day, exists mostly on the periphery, in the smaller-press scenes. Like in every other art form, and in society at large, people—readers, pundits, retailers, publishers—are largely conservative and don’t adapt to change very well. We tend to reject things that are unfamiliar to us.
Comics’ history is short, but it’s filled with instances of the industry’s conservatism: overcoming house styles, mediations on race and the mainstream press’ seeming dismissal of international and outlier success. Bernard Krigstein’s brief but innovative time will forever help us remember that fact.