9.0

Shin Megami Tensei V Is a Meditative Trip Through Hell

Games Reviews shin megami tensei
Share Tweet Submit Pin
<i>Shin Megami Tensei V</i> Is a Meditative Trip Through Hell

I had my doubts about Shin Megami Tensei V. Since Sega’s purchase of Atlus in 2013, I’ve felt ambivalent about the direction the series has taken. Much like Dragon Quest, SMT has long been a bastion of the “old school” in the RPG sphere—the changes in the formula are far more incremental than many of their peers, but there’s an undeniable and marked evolution between each entry that feels considered and correct for each game and the time period in which they were released. The process accelerated just a bit too fast in Shin Megami Tensei IV, then leaned in harder in Shin Megami Tensei IV: Apocalypse and Strange Journey Redux.

Many of these changes were a direct result of a change in hands. SMTIV was the first game in the mainline series where Kazuma Kaneko was not the primary character or demon designer, and the role of creative director had been passed to Eiji Ishida. Masayuki Doi, known for his work on the Trauma Center series, designed the main cast while a cavalcade of new demons were completed by Doi and a retinue of guest artists mostly known for their work on Sentai series such as Kamen Rider. The result was a rather scatterbrained melange of Kaneko’s designs throughout the years and several new designs that seemed to align poorly with Kaneko’s house style. Where Kaneko became renowned for predominantly keeping his demon designs loyal to their original myths (while still remaining interpretive or reverent of popular fashion of the time, hence the many Jean Paul Gaultier-esque designs in Nocturne), many of the demon designs of SMTIV felt ridiculous and unrecognizable to the original myths, slapping lasers, gross appendages, and fleshy abs on archangels and legendary warriors seemingly in the name of cool. I would compare the experience to playing a gacha game, where occasionally you encounter a design that feels like a spark of genius amid a sea of the strange and off-putting. This coupled with the inane plots of Apocalypse and Strange Journey Redux very well could have turned me off from the series forever if the gameplay hadn’t been so finely tuned.

What sold me on Shin Megami Tensei V was seeing firsthand how Doi came into his own as an integral part of the series. The new designs he spearheaded show a dogged maturity, and his new vision for the series—grotesque, ferocious, and passionate—meld perfectly with the central themes at hand in SMTV. The game feels like a triumph in many ways, imbued with new life and palpably raw as it blends Shin Megami Tensei’s history with a modern outlook. Much of this lies in the visual design of the game.

The demons that blot Tokyo feel achingly alive; their animations are fluid, sinister, and sometimes quite sweet. They seem inviting, or vile, and vie for power with desperation. They serve greater beings like good peons and have much to say about the goings-on of Da’at, of which there are a myriad of moving parts. Seeing the demons roam around the open frontier makes them feel more integrated into the world than in SMTIV, which did away with random encounters in the series but was only able to render demons as pixelated holograms due to the 3DS’s limitations. The many side quests offered by the fairies and goddesses that populate the world give them a distinct personality, making them feel like more than just collectable Pokémon. They’re beings with desires grander than humans—it feels like justice to the many mythologies and religions represented.

As the game progresses, the cosmology that SMTV posits seems more and more understandable, despite its rarefied subject matter. The plot itself is fairly straightforward, and feels like a callback to the original Shin Megami Tensei as well as Nocturne. What begins as your classic tale of God versus Satan gradually unravels into a race towards divinity—it’s esoteric, but nothing would be out of place in a late ‘80s seinen manga. The pacing of the story is rather glacial; the stakes don’t begin to rise until around the game’s mid-point. The slow progression often works in the game’s favor, though, giving an impression of impossible blockades and labors that must be overcome to reach your ultimate destination.

The game is set amid a backdrop of post-apocalyptic Tokyo, which has been transformed by the forces of chaos into an arid desert. It can’t be understated how effective the setting in SMTV truly is—specks of sand create hazy beige fog hiding ferocious Hydras and Chimeras. Buildings are toppled onto parking garages, creating intricate, architectural nightmare mazes that are difficult to parse or pass through. Iconic structures of Tokyo have been repurposed as holy meeting grounds or demonic castles, which teem with ancient life and seem sickeningly infested.

I won’t pretend like the Switch’s technical limitations confound some of the atmosphere—the game is plagued with pop-in and slow loading textures—but spaces still retain a deep sense of mythicism and terror, thanks in part to the game’s wonderful soundtrack. Ryota Kozuka and Toshiki Konishi create a storm of anxiety and awe with their deft blend of industrial drone, chant, and propulsive synth-metal that is often just understated enough to foster a unique, dreamlike haze. It’s possibly the Switch’s best sounding game this year next to Metroid Dread.

The gameplay remains mostly undisturbed from IV with some fairly major additions. In particular, the game features a new system called the Magatsuhi Gauge, a bar that slowly fills during battle when certain actions are taken similar to Final Fantasy X’s Overdrive system. When the bar fills completely, the team can release a Magatsuhi ability, which is something like a super move that doesn’t consume a turn to use. The effects of these Magatsuhi abilities depend on the race of the demon using them, and can be anything from the highly situational to the borderline overpowered. It’s a dynamic system that, in true SMT fashion, can be exploited by enemies as well, which makes the mad dash to fill the gauge feel like a decisive path to victory. Also introduced are skill potentials, which can improve or impair the Nahobino and his demons’ ability to use certain elemental moves. This coupled with the highly customizable Essence and Miracle systems add a lot of strategy to planning how to expend the various resources you’re given throughout the game, and tailor an individual run as a unique and experimental experience. Like past entries, it’s entirely possible to exploit these systems to create near-impervious teams perfect for dominating all the game’s encounters.

There’s a noticeable focus on platforming, which has never been a particular focus of exploration in the series so far. The execution of the platforming is varied; it feels wonderful to move around in SMTV, but the Nahobino’s jump is less well-designed, resulting in many overly precise maneuvers required to get around. There’s also some fairly dated dungeon puzzles that are sure to frustrate anyone that hasn’t recently played a PS2 JRPG. Dungeon-crawling is mostly serviceable nevertheless, and these roadblocks are thankfully few and far between.

SMTV’s anarchic tone, relatively high difficulty ceiling, and heavy focus on combat might turn away some players, but it has an undeniable gravity and ultimately proves itself as an exceptional RPG. The grind to the top is ascetic and practiced, with grand ambition and keen diligence towards paying the franchise’s history its proper dues. It’s an undeniably dark game, but quite optimistic in its intentions and eschews edgy clichés. Shin Megami Tensei V is Atlus’s contemporary masterpiece, and one of the finest games this year.


Shin Megami Tensei V was developed by Atlus and published by Sega. It is available for the Switch.

Austin Jones is a writer with eclectic media interests. You can chat with him about horror games, electronic music, Joanna Newsom and ‘80s-‘90s anime on Twitter @belfryfire