Reality TV gets a bad rap. That’s right, I said it. Again. The genre may not be viewed in the same light as prestige TV, but fans of living vicariously through the actions or misdeeds of others are in for a treat during the final months of 2023 anyway.
With the writers and actors strikes dragging on, reality programming will be filling up more lineups than ever this fall. Every network and streamer broke their glass case marked “Use Only in Case of a Prolonged Strike” months ago, and the reality TV deluge is about to hit.
To be sure, there will be some reality duds this fall, but I’m here to separate the wheat from the chaff. The 10 shows listed here are the creme de la creme of the fall reality TV schedule. A blend of old favorites, shows with unique twists, and series with concepts that could potentially break the internet make this a list that’s sure to offer something for every type of TV viewer.
Welcome to Wrexham
Network: FX (Streaming on Hulu)
Premiere Date: September 12
Few series demonstrate the power of reality TV better than Welcome to Wrexham. The surprisingly heartwarming story of two Hollywood actors buying a fifth tier Welsh soccer club sounds like a bizarre storyline from Ted Lasso. However, this unique series ended up being one of the surprise hits of 2022. The docuseries returns for a second season with Wrexham Dragons team owners Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney greeting King Charles, recovering from last season’s painful playoff elimination, and a battle with a new rival for promotion.
Wrestlers
Network: Netflix
Premiere Date: September 13
Wrestlers is the pro wrestling version of Welcome to Wrexham, with touches of the Starz wrestling drama Heels starring Stephen Amell thrown in for good measure. This new reality series offers a detailed look at the real life regional wrestling gym Ohio Valley Wrestling, whose alums include John Cena, Brock Lesnar, and Dave Bautista. I have watched the first two episodes, and it’s a fascinating examination of lower tier athletes desperately chasing their dreams, the diehard fans who love them, and a struggling ownership group. Sound familiar?
Love is Blind
Network: Netflix
Premiere Date: September 22
The Nick and Vanessa Lachey-hosted series returns for its fifth season and continues to make The Bachelor look as wholesome as a glass of warm milk by comparison. Despite a seemingly sweet premise (Can you truly fall in love with someone sight unseen?), Love is Blind has always been loaded with shady moments. From Shake asking women what they weigh in the pods and later comparing his fiance Deepti to his aunt, Jessica (aka Messica) constantly and drunkenly embarrassing herself, and Andrew using eyedrops to make it look like he’s crying after getting dumped, Love is Blind is the kind of dating series that’s cringe-inducing yet also allows you to laugh at attractive people doing moronic things.
Below Deck Mediterranean
Network: Bravo
Premiere Date: September 25
Bravo has done a great job of turning the Below Deck franchise into a year-round series with one iteration airing immediately after another, and that’s just fine by me. This fall it’s Below Deck Med’s turn, with the Captain Sandy-led crew sailing into its eighth season. Also returning are Season 7 stews Natalya and Kyle, who are now taking orders from new chief stew Tumi, who BD fans may remember as a second stew from Below Deck Down Under. Looking to shake things up is another recognizable face, deckhand Luka, who made his debut in the most recent season of Down Under. A bit of a ladies man who looks like the younger brother of James Franco, Luca is sure to bring the drama.
