River’s level continues to riseThe cover of 2007’s The Stage Names featured a hand waving outstretched toward an embroidered, sunburst sky, basking in the glow of celebrity exposure.The Stand Ins
This thorny relationship is conceptualized, schematized, scrutinized and historicized on The Stand Ins through characters like glam-rocker Jobriath and a now-famous actresses’ pining ex-boyfriend. And Okkervil River itself performs here with an organic ease that’s dramatic without reaching for histrionics, continuing to tattoo its rough folkish flesh with Motown horns (“Starry Stairs”), power-pop overdrive (“Pop Lie”) and chugging New Wave bass (“Lost Coastlines”). The inclusion of three orchestral interludes, along with singer Will Sheff’s easing off the words-per-measure count a bit, lend some welcome breathing room to the set.
Although The Stand Ins has been called the sequel to The Stage Names and emerges from the same recording sessions —something Okkervil River also did with Black Sheep Boy Appendix—this album is not just a subsequence. It’s an interlocking, overlapping element that loops back, through and even forward. “Lost Coastlines,” the album’s first proper song, sets its sights on the band’s own struggles. And after Sheff and since-departed Jonathan Meiburg (now focusing on his band Shearwater) wail together “we have lost our way / but nobody`s gonna say it outright,” the track hits, retracts and then comes back twice as strong—an elegy to what’s always being lost, even as an achievement like The Stand Ins is only beginning.