In many ways, Let My Puppets Come is as delightfully silly as you’d hope. The cast is introduced at the start with an extended credits sequence, in which each of the puppets are given punny stage names like “Connie Lingus” and “Roberto Vaselini.” There are quite a few musical numbers—one might say too many—including a song starring a mustachioed phallus. The movie comes across as a series of sketches strung together more than anything else. Being pretty slapdash narratively is true to form for the pornography genre; nevertheless, Let My Puppets Come is jam-packed with goofy moments. It bears saying, too, that there are many grim reminders that this is a film made in 1976. The only Black puppet is merely named “Black Girl,” and there are jokes made about carceral rape and at the expense of trans people. This is definitely a movie of its time.
Let My Puppets Come goes hard (no pun intended) with the first sex scene, which is between a puppet woman and her puppet dog. Yes, you read that correctly. This is also the only scene showing penetrative sex between puppets, which makes sense once you think about the fact that it would be difficult for the puppeteers to aim one puppet’s genitalia into the other’s. The rest of the scenes feature a lot of puppet blow jobs and, with the puppets’ mouths shaped the way they are, this ends up involving hilarious chomping motions on felt penises. Even when live action female performers are introduced, they’re given unusual tasks, like the one woman (Penny Nicholls) who throws grapes at a puppet to satisfy his kink. In short, the sex in Let My Puppets Come is intended to be uproarious rather than titillating.
Setting the bestiality scene aside, there’s something joyous in the film’s view of sex as a laughable, strange pursuit, rather than the overly reverent lens favored by the public these days. There’s been much said about how Gen Z are sex-negative when it comes to the portrayal of physical intimacy in entertainment. Most recently, that’s become apparent in the criticism of Jenna Ortega and Martin Freeman’s sex scene in the 2024 film Miller’s Girl, in which the pair play a student and teacher, respectively. There’s a 31 year age gap between the actors, which perturbed some viewers during the scene, but these people forget that Ortega and Freeman are colleagues given many forms of protection thanks to the work of the production’s intimacy coordinator.
I’m not claiming to know anything about the conditions on the set of Let My Puppets Come. Rather, I’m saying that a movie approaching sex with a sense of playfulness feels like a breath of fresh air, something I wasn’t expecting from a film made nearly 50 years ago. Human bodies are weird and funny, and so is the act of bringing them together—a hilarity that’s exponentially increased when you get puppets involved.
Clare Martin is a cemetery enthusiast and Paste’s assistant comedy editor. Go harass her on Twitter @theclaremartin.