Late Night Last Week: John Oliver on the Cruelty of Deportations, Gutfeld Makes Tonight Show Debut, and More

Late Night Last Week: John Oliver on the Cruelty of Deportations, Gutfeld Makes Tonight Show Debut, and More
Introducing Endless Mode: A New Games & Anime Site from Paste

As the business of late night has come to dominate national headlines, one man has remained steady, proving that while the old modes may be dying, the genre itself will endure. The grim reaper may come for network television, but John Oliver is forever. 

On August 10, Oliver cut right to the chase, forgoing his usual pre-monologue joke roll to dive into the night’s topic: immigration. Specifically, Oliver covered the Trump Administration’s ruthless deportation efforts, which even those once sympathetic to his cause believe have gone too far. The campaign promise was to target violent criminals, not the ice cream man. Yes, as Oliver discussed, in Los Angeles, the beloved neighborhood ice cream man was seized by masked men in an unmarked car and detained. And it’s happening all over the country. 

In his monologue, Oliver goes on to point out the problem the administration faces. They ran a campaign fueled by fear-mongering about immigrants, promising to deport one million people. But the fact of the matter is, the “threat” is not nearly as great as they made voters believe. Thus, they are targeting the ice cream man. 

“They’ve backed thmselves into this corner, because promising to deport a million criminal immigrants is one thing, but once you’re in charge, you then have to find that many of them,” Oliver said, “which is going to be hard if they don’t exist in the numbers that you’re claiming, which they don’t.”

“It’s like promising to apprehend 10,000 Fred Dursts a day,” Oliver added. “There just aren’t that many out there.” 

Oliver’s monologue is yet another example of his preternatural ability to tackle the absurdity of our current moment without erasing the depravity. For example, he describes the administration’s focus on “expedited removals.” Basically, because those with pending immigration cases cannot be deported, ICE agents are detaining migrants, bringing them to court to have the cases quickly dismissed, and then taking them into custody again to deport them. If the person has been in the United States fewer than two years, they can be subjected to “expedited removal.” 

“That is all awful, very much including the term ‘expedited removal,’” Oliver said, “which sounds less like a legal process and more like a phrase you see with an exclamation point on the packaging of a particularly powerful laxative.” 

Perhaps the biggest late night story of the week was the appearance of the self-described “King of Late Night” on the genre’s most venerated program. On August 7, Fox News’ Greg Gutfeld, host of an eponymous 10 pm show, joined Jimmy Fallon for a discussion on The Tonight Show. It was underwhelming.

If you’re unfamiliar with Gutfeld, here is one example of his comedic genius. On Gutfeld! last month, the host said that conservatives “need to learn from the Blacks.” His point: “The way they were able to remove the power from the n-word by using it. So, from now on, it’s ‘What up, my Nazi? Hey, what up, my Nazi? Hey, what’s hanging, my Nazi?’”

This man will probably win the Mark Twain Prize for American Humor. I wish I was joking

The conversation with Fallon was a whole lot of nothing. Most of the appearance centered on a weird drunken encounter Gutfeld and Fallon had at a bar years ago, before then pivoting to a dreadful-looking reality television show Gutfeld will be hosting on Fox Nation. Gutfeld seemed unsure of what to do with himself, seemingly pleased and in disbelief to have found himself on television outside the Fox bubble. 

What made the interview so painful was less the guest and more the host. It was all so boring. Fallon asked Gutfeld absolutely nothing of interest. Nothing about politics, nothing about his cocky claims about being the king of late night, nor Gutfeld’s critiques of network television’s current, liberal-leaning approach. A philosophical debate on the nature of comedic media was not needed, but a little substance would have gone a long way to making the conversation interesting, and perhaps, maybe, just a little bit, fruitful. 

Meanwhile, Stephen Colbert said goodbye before taking his final summer break as the host of Late Night. The monologue centered on Trump’s tariffs, including a visit by Apple CEO Tim Cook to the White House, where he gave Trump some sort of ugly 24-karat gold trinket. 

At the same event, Trump also held a press conference, during which he mentioned Colbert and the two Jimmys. Trump claimed they all had no talent and predicted that Fallon and Kimmel would be next to go. Colbert, Trump pointed out, has the highest ratings.

“To be fair,” Colbert said in response, “I think we’re all equally untalented.” 

Since the cancellation, Colbert’s ratings have continued to rise. According to LateNighter, Colbert crushed both Kimmel (who aired reruns) and Fallon the final week of July. He averaged a 12.51% weekly share compared to Fallon’s 4.74%. He has also seen a boost in the crown jewel of television, the 18-49 demo. Is a corporate backtrack on the horizon? 

Finally, we end with Bill Hader. On August 8, he joined his old friend Seth Meyers for a conversation about many things, including their time on Saturday Night Live. The subject of the program’s 50th anniversary special came up, and specifically, Hader’s absence. That the show went on without Hader, without question one of the best cast members in the show’s history, was the subject of disappointment among fans.

As Meyers noted, Hader has been quite open about his anxiety, which was heightened when he was on the show. Meyers also mentioned Andy Samberg’s short he made for the special about the anxiety that comes with being a cast member—Hader respectfully declined the part. 

“When he told me about it, I was like, ‘I don’t know if I want to do that.’ And he was like, ‘Why?!’” Hader remembered with a laugh. “And I’m like, ‘Because I’m anxious!’” 

Just when we thought he couldn’t get any more likeable and relatable, Bill Hader proves us wrong. 


 Will DiGravio is a Brooklyn-based critic, researcher, and late night comedy columnist, who first contributed to Paste in 2022. He is an assistant editor at Cineaste, a GALECA member, and since 2019 has hosted The Video Essay Podcast. You can follow and/or unfollow him on Twitter and learn more about him via his website.

 
Join the discussion...