Community: “Custody Law and Eastern European Diplomacy” (2.18)

Community has garnered such a fanbase not just because it has particularly tight writing, which it does, but also because of the way it breaks away from being a sit-com. And no, while I’ve talked a lot about the ways it’s different from traditional sit-coms, that’s not what I’m concerned with here. It’s that the show’s also different from post-The Office and Arrested Development sit-coms. It breaks rules that exist around single-camera shows and the sort of reality they ask us to agree on in a way that, for instance, Modern Family or Outsourced won’t.
Examples of that sort of creativity come with the shows more unique, theme-driven episodes, such as the Christmas special or the zombie invasion. These are fan favorites not just because they’re really good genre parodies, but also because they take the show into places that traditionally remain unexplored by live-action sit-coms, regardless of when they’re being made. They may be gimmicky, but that’s about the only complaint that can be leveled at them.
That being said, with 24 episodes a season Community just can’t do that many gimmicks, due to both time and expense. I would also hazard that interest is another reason why it doesn’t do that type of episode every week; despite its flexible reality the show is interested in grounding its characters. Some of the remaining episodes will still be very good, but they’re also more sit-com-y and tend just to be not as strong for various reasons.
“Custody Law and Eastern European Diplomacy” for one thing gives Pierce and Annie virtually no screentime in the episode, which is understandable given the large cast size but still regrettable. Community is always at its best when everyone is involved. Its more important plot is related to Chang’s wish to be part of Shirley’s child’s life, which goes against her will. When she asks Jeff to convince him to sign a contract relinquishing his parental rights, Chang reacts by trying to emulate what he believes a good father is like.