Bitter Cocktails for (Anti) Valentine’s Day

Drink Lists Valentine's Day cocktails
Bitter Cocktails for (Anti) Valentine’s Day

I’ve said it before, but if you’re breaking out in a sweat because you haven’t made the right restaurant reservation yet and you’re afraid your Other Half is going to be Doghousing you, or you’re single and grumpy about it, I will say it again: Valentine’s Day isn’t really about love anyway.

February 14th is the feast day, according to the Catholic calendar, of Saint Valentine of Terni, a 3rd century Roman martyr. Very little is known about him except that he was beheaded on February 14, 269 CE. It’s not even completely clear how or why he ever became associated with courtly love. Celebrating Saint Valentine is not even required by the church: He’s in the “if you don’t have a more important guy to venerate on that day” portion of the hagiographies. My point obviously being that if the Holy See considers it an optional celebration, you totes have permission to do likewise.

So, now that you’re staying home and devoting your Romantic Evening time to getting soused, I propose that you pick a cocktail with a focus on bitters, because… well, I don’t need to explain that, right?

Bitters are a little confusing because they cover a wide and ever-increasing range of products, but the main deal is, they are a neutral spirit base infused with any number of botanicals, they originally developed as medicines and many do indeed have strong medicinal properties, and they’re very concentrated, so you use them by the drop or dash rather the way you would use vanilla extract in baking. An explosion of house-made and craft-distiller bitters based on every single thing you can think of and many things you maybe can’t has dominated cocktail culture in recent years and shows no sign of abating, so you have lots of options to play with.

A couple of the classic cocktails any self-respecting home bartender should be able to whip up are defined by their bitters: the Sazerac by Peychaud bitters, the Manhattan and the Old-Fashioned, among many, by Angostura bitters, both of which have been around for-flippin’-ever. Craft bitters are, however, proliferating in every imaginable direction, and while some are easier to find than others, here are a few ways to go beyond the Old-Fashioned and into the Newfangled.

As a bonus, many of these cocktails happen to be a striking red color. You know, like blood. And, some are super-simple and a few are master class situations (I haven’t personally gone anywhere near that Bazaar Bloody Maria, it’s way over my pay grade). But hopefully there’s something bitter for you to try at any level of cocktail-moxie.

Happy freakin’ V-Day and may the expression “bottoms up” mean something way cooler at your house than it probably will at mine.

Maker’s Love

makers love.jpg

1 ½ parts Maker’s Mark Bourbon
¾ part Aperol
Dash rhubarb bitters
Splash of white vermouth (Dolin Blanc Vermouth de Chambery is suggested)
Orange zest for garnish

Directions: Rinse martini glass with a little absinthe and ice, stir and let sit. Fill a shaker with ice, add Maker’s Mark Bourbon, Aperol, bitters, and vermouth and stir gently. Discard the ice and absinthe and strain the cocktail into the glass. Garnish with a strip of orange zest.

Raspberry Beret

Raspberry Beret.jpeg
Created by Jordan Brower for Slowly Shirley NYC
Photo credit Nick Vorderman

3/4 oz. Bourbon (Jordan favors Elijah Craig)
4 Raspberries, muddled
3/4 oz. Lemon juice
3/4 oz. Ginger syrup
1-1/2 oz. Luxardo Bitters
Top: soda
Garnish: Raspberry and candied ginger

Directions: Muddle the raspberries first. Shake all ingredients together with 3 ice cubes. Strain into a Collins glass. Top with soda. Garnish with candied ginger.

The Legacy

The Legacy at Bar Belly.jpeg
Available at Bar Belly NYC
Photo by Amanda Watenberg

1 1/2 oz. D’usse Cognac
1/2 oz. Cocchi Rose vermouth
1/2 oz. Nonino Amaro
1/2 oz. Wolffer Estate Verjus
5 drops Bittermans Burlesque Bitters

Directions: Stir all ingredients in a mixing glass and pour into coupe glass.

Love of a Lifethyme

Love of a Lifethyme.jpeg
Created by Lucinda Sterling, Middle Branch

1 oz. Patrón Silver
.5 oz. lemon juice
.25 oz. pomegranate syrup
.25 oz. honey
2 dashes Peychaud’s bitters

Directions: Shake first five ingredients with ice. Then strain into an absinthe-rinsed coupe, top with a float of Prosecco and garnish with a fresh thyme sprig.

Common Sense

Common Sense.jpeg
Created by Steve Schneider, Employees Only

1.75 oz. The Macallan Sherry Oak 12 Years Old
1 oz. Dolin Blanc
.75 oz. Averna Amaro
1 dash Bitter Truth spiced Chocolate bitters

Directions: Add ingredients to a mixing glass. Add ice, stir and strain in a chilled coupe. Garnish with a lemon zest.

Bazaar Bloody Maria

Bazaar Bloody Maria.jpeg
Created by Pam Wiznitzer, Trademark & Belle Shoals

2 oz. Patron Reposado
2 oz. Water
.75 oz. Lemon juice
2 tbsp Worcestershire sauce (UK)
3 dashes Bitterman’s Hellfire Bitters
5 dashes Horseradish tincture
Red tomatoes + pinch Piri Piri (Portugal)
Orange tomatoes + Habanero (South America)
Yellow tomatoes + Saffron (India)
Green tomatoes + Zaatar (Middle East)
Pinch salt
Pinch pepper

Directions: To make ice cubes: Blend ingredients together thoroughly and strain for seeds.
The night before, make the Bloody Maria ice cubes and freeze each color individually.

In a highball glass, Crush/smash 1-2 Bloody Maria ice cubes of each tomato color. Fill the highball glass with the ice, layering by color.

In a separate glass, combine 2 oz. Patrón Reposado, .75 oz. lemon juice, 3 dashes Bitterman’s Hellfire Bitters, 5 dashes Horseradish Tincture.

Pour mixture into the highball glass over ice. Add straw and garnish with a skewer that has multicolored tomatoes, fresh squash blossom, exotic international peppers and celery with leaf still attached

Macallan Maple Old Fashioned Cocktail

macallan cocktail proofs.jpeg
Created by James Frankhouse of Goodnight Sonny

2 oz. The Macallan Sherry Oak 12 Years Old
¼ oz. fig rosemary maple syrup
2 dashes angostura bitters
2 dashes orange bitters

Directions: Combine sherry, fig rosemary maple syrup and bitters. Serve in rocks glass with ice ball. Garnish with rosemary sprig, lemon peel and orange peel.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Share Tweet Submit Pin