Cloud Drifts Between Two Tones: Disturbing Grifter Thriller and Boilerplate Action Yarn

This review is based on a screening at the 60th Chicago International Film Festival, and originally ran in Oct. 2024.
Kiyoshi Kurosawa is such a prolific director that his latest film, Cloud, isn’t even his sole contribution to 2024. Inalongside Cloud at Beyond Fest. Three films in a single year—what are the odds that they all exemplify Kurosawa at his finest?
fact, Cloud caps off what may be the filmmaker’s busiest year yet: His for-whom-the-bell-tolls horror/thriller Chime dropped in the first quarter of the year, while The Serpent’s Path, a remake of his 1998 film of the same name, made its U.S. premiereI wouldn’t suggest taking bets on Cloud being the standout Kurosawa offering of 2024. This curious action-thriller, which centers on an unscrupulous online reseller who has a violent showdown with his disgruntled buyers (played by Masaki Suda of The Boy and the Heron and the 2021 Cube remake), features most of the director’s formal hallmarks, if not his finesse. The film has long, steady stretches of creeping unease, gnarly interpersonal relationships, and plenty of destructive determination, yet these parts, once assembled, create a cacophony of grinding tones. As a thriller, Cloud is half of a fascinating, disquieting, grimly amusing satire of online chicanery. As an action movie, it’s chaotic and vague, grasping to voice a critique of our digitally warped capitalistic age. “What price profit?” Cloud asks. When Kurosawa finally smashes these two halves into one, you might be indifferent to the answer.
“Impulse and instinct. That’s how I operate,” says cool, ambitious Ryosuke Yoshii (Suda), an online flipper who has learned to respect the hustle of buying low and selling high. Put more directly, he acquires cheap goods from desperate folks and sells them at an exploitative markup. At first, Yoshii revels in his trade; his first flip—a lot of medical equipment—yields over $27,300 (4,200,000 yen) after dropping a measly 580 bucks on their former owners. As the zeros increase in his bank account, Yoshii develops a refined taste for this racket. His factory boss, Takimoto (Yoshiyoshi Arakawa), sees his drive as a leadership quality and offers him a higher position: “You’re resourceful and committed,” he says, to which Yoshii dismissively replies, “I’m just unassertive. It only looks like I’m committed.”