The Buccaneers Season 2 Gives Its Mature Female Characters a Chance to Shine

The cast and creatives behind The Buccaneers discuss putting the series' older female characters center stage.

The Buccaneers Season 2 Gives Its Mature Female Characters a Chance to Shine

The Buccaneers is a period drama that’s all about youth. In a world were costume dramas are often assumed to be stiff and overly serious—all those corsets and quiet pining!— the Apple TV+ series is the complete opposite, an unapologetic riot of noisy, colorful, youthful excess that’s all about friendship and the particular messy escapades that so often come with coming of age. The story of a group of American heiresses who head to England in the hopes of marrying titled British aristocrats, the series depicts a group of friends who crash headlong into the upper echelons of British society and must face the harsh truths of growing up that follow. 

The series’ second season turns things up to eleven, powering through plot twists, romances, secrets, and betrayals at a positively breakneck pace. It features contemporary pop ballads, wildly anachronistic costuming choices, and plenty of youthful indiscretions, even as most of its leads are tentatively navigating their first steps into the world of marriage and children. But despite its overtly youthful focus, The Buccaneers Season 2 still makes time to do something that feels rather remarkable: Focus on the mature women of its story.  

Perhaps this shouldn’t feel as surprising as it is, given that The Buccaneers is a show that’s so unapologetic about the idea that there must be space for other kinds of female experiences and desires beyond simply finding a man with a title and a sizable estate to marry. But allowing, let’s just call it “women of a certain age” to drive their own stories is something vanishingly rare in this particular genre space—heck, on television in general—and that deserves to be celebrated whenever possible. And The Buccaneers doesn’t just allow one of its older women to have the spotlight, but several. 

“With all of the mothers and older characters in the show—with the Dowager Duchess, and Mrs. St. George and even Lady Brightlingsea and Mrs. Elmsworth, actually—that you start out thinking that these are just the “mum” characters and that you know what those kinds of figures in a period drama are meant to be like,” series creator, writer and executive producer  Katherine Jakeways tells Paste. They’re those kinds of people. There’s nothing new here.”

But The Buccaneers Season 2 purposefully chooses a different path. From widowhood and new romances to long-held family secrets, the series’ older generation women have plenty of drama and problems of their own to deal with in Season 2, all of which impact their relationships with their daughters (or daughters-in-law). 

“As we grow up, something we discover about our own mothers is that they had lives of their own. They fell in love, and they made mistakes. They did good things and bad things and feel good about some [of their choices] and regret others,” Jakeways continues. “Obviously, the girls and the boys and the love stories are such a big part of the show, but I feel that this season we’ve also really fleshed out the older characters and leaned into the push and pull of those relationships.” 

For Mrs. St. George (Christina Hendricks), that means navigating the lifetime’s worth of lies that are finally coming home to roost. Now that she’s finally succeeded in getting her daughter Nan (Kristine Frøseth) married, she must deal with her crumbling relationship with her unfaithful husband, to the surprise appearance of her younger sister Nell (Leighton Meister), who is also secretly Nan’s biological mother. 

“I think it’s wonderful,” Hendricks says.”I assumed at the beginning [of this show] that our demographic was going to be younger women, and it actually covers a much larger age range than you’d expect. And I think it’s nice to see storylines with different age groups. And I was excited to hear what they pitched for [Mrs. St. George] this season, it felt like an important one. It’s a reflection of how far we’ve come and how far we need to go.”

The decision to make Nan’s birth mother someone much closer to the family than anyone probably expected “came really early on” during the season’s planning process. 

“We asked ourselves: how do we make this interesting? Why do we care? The colonel has probably had a million affairs with different women. We wanted it to be someone who felt worthy of Nan and whom we felt the audience would care about,” Jakeways says. “The idea that it was Nell was especially fascinating because she’s Mrs. St. George’s younger sister and we could play with all the ways that they’ve framed this situation over the 19 years since Nan was born—how they’ve made each other the villain in this story and have blamed each other and grown apart and protected their own [roles] in that story.”

The sisters haven’t seen each other for over a decade, after all, and both have rather firm opinions about which of them is in the wrong when it comes to their estrangement. Patti’s still (fairly, if we’re honest) angry that her younger sister slept with her husband, while Nell resents that she’s taken the bulk of the blame for everything from the affairs to the decades long cover up of Nan’s parentage, when Tracy St. George (Adam James)  was equally at fault. 

“We wanted to know how it would impact them both when they got together on Nan’s wedding day and finally talked about it and saw each other’s point of view,” Jakeways continues. “Maybe they realize the two of them were not the ones that were really to blame and there was somebody else they should have been blaming all along.” 

Nell’s also (both understandably and perhaps a bit irrationally) angry that her sister is finally standing up for herself and planning to leave her dirtbag spouse, simply because she refused to do it all those years ago when it would have helped protect her from Tracy’s advances.

“We always have a phrase we use in the writers’ room: ‘What’s the 2025 element of this? Yes, it’s a period show, but what’s our 2025 perspective?”  executive producer Beth Willis explains. “And with Mrs. St. George, her having knowingly or not knowingly never acknowledged how young Nell was when she had the relationship with the Colonel, and therefore, if blame is to be laid, what responsibility did Mrs. St. George, as a mother figure in that household to her younger sister felt quite contemporary. It also feels like something that Mrs. St. George has never talked about with Nell before the wedding day. And when Mrs. St. George says, “Oh, Nan’s too young to cope with all this information,” Nell replies that ‘She’s older than I was when your husband took me to bed,’ it’s a moment that really clicks for her. That felt like one of our 2025 moments. Despite it being two incredible powerhouse women in period dresses in a period house, it felt very contemporary to us.” 

But Patti and Nell aren’t the only older women getting significant story arcs in Season 2. In one of the season’s most unexpected and best surprises, The Buccaneers gives some fascinating new layers and shading to its most imperious character: The Dowager Duchess of Tintagel (Amelia Bullmore). On a less interesting version of this show, Blanche would have likely been little more than a caricature, a villainous older woman desperate to hold on to her family’s power. But in The Buccaneers, she’s something much more than that.

“The Dowager is so amazing,” Jakeways laughs. “I think she’s who we all want to be when we grow up, honestly. She’s not necessarily villainous at the beginning of Season 1, but absolutely, she starts out as the establishment. All she wants to do is get her son married, and she’s kind of a bit forbidding. But what we loved about the character, and about the way Amelia plays her—and she’s done such a fantastic job—is that it underlines the idea that all the characters in our show are not just one thing. Everybody has moments of being both good and bad. They evolve. And the Dowager has this facade of being absolutely by the book and all about the establishment, but she’s so much more than that. Which we see in this love story in Season 2, and we were so excited to get the chance to tell.”

In much the same way that Patti and Nell’s relationship is used to explore more adult questions of sisterhood, loyalty, and family in ways that often mirror or invert Nan and Jinny’s (Imogen Waterhouse) bond, Blanche’s Season 2 arc is also one part aspirational and one part cautionary tale. The sudden reappearance of her long-ago love, Reede Robinson (Greg Wise) not only allows us to see a “softer side” of the Dowager, but also offers an important new perspective on Nan and Theo’s (Guy Remmers) relationship.

“This relationship really expands who the Dowager is and allows us to explore her [on her own] more fully,” Jakeways says. “To understand that she had her own Guy Thwarte, that she had let love pass her boy all those years ago, and she did in the name of protecting Tintagel and the institution, it makes you see her in a different light. Suddenly, all those things she did in Season 1, and indeed that she might do in Season 2 when she’s particularly brutal with people, they make a certain kind of sense now. The institution must come first, because she’s sacrificed so much for it. And maybe she regrets it, maybe she’s looking at these young people thinking, ‘Am I doing the right thing, forcing them into the same mistakes I made?’ Or is she thinking, ‘No, I’ve sacrificed and you should sacrifice too.’

It also doesn’t hurt that Blanche and Reede are 100% adorable together, demonstrating the sort of delightful chemistry and weapons-grade pining that’s as swoon-worthy as any of the romances the younger girls are involved in. 

“It really does illuminate her [more fully] as a person, having that relationship,” Wilils says. “And it’s so interesting that Chappell Roan is playing over that first moment that they look at each other across the dance floor in Episode 3, partly because it’s so romantic and it’s so fun and so contemporary. It’s a great reminder that you’re as young as you feel, and in that moment, they really feel young again. They’re a pleasure to watch.” 

The Buccaneers is now streaming on Apple TV+.


Lacy Baugher Milas writes about TV and Books at Paste Magazine, but loves nerding out about all sorts of pop culture. You can find her on Twitter and Bluesky at @LacyMB

For all the latest TV news, reviews, lists and features, follow @Paste_TV

 
Join the discussion...