Merlefest 2005 – Day 2

photos [L-R]: The Merlefest crowd gives the Avett Brothers a standing ovation after their performance on the Austin stage, Scott Avett strums his banjo
After a long day working the Paste booth on vendor row—meeting as many people as we could and getting the word out about the magazine—our four-person Merlefest team is ready for some music.
We power-walk it over to the Austin stage where, nestled cozily against an Appalachian hillside, a few hundred festival-goers are in the midst of getting rocked by North Carolina acoustic trio The Avett Brothers. Blaring steel-string guitar, strummed banjo, plunking upright bass and vibrant, rough-edged harmonies fill the mini-amphitheatre as the band cranks through old-timey songs of heartbreak, woe and adventure on the high seas. Guitarist Seth Avett keeps time, stomping a hi-hat with his foot. They have a hard time staying in tune (and keeping their strings from snapping), but it doesn’t matter much. When the Avetts start singing, something magical happens—the way their voices blend when belting their harmonies is mesmerizing.
Steve Douglas from old Atlanta band The Shiners—a band that used to share bills with folks like Trailer Bride and the Drive-By Truckers—turns to me and says, “There’s a new Redneck Underground.” I can’t argue with him. The Avett Brothers’ reckless rock ’n’ roll approach to traditional folk has a lot in common, spiritually, with the aforementioned bands, even if the sound is different. The Avetts’ dreamy acoustic ballads and revved-up gutterpunk folkgrass conjure visions of some ballsy, demented, hick version of Crosby, Stills and Nash.
Seth abandons the hi-hat, opting instead to furiously stomp his foot, clickin’ and clackin’ up a storm on the wooden stage. At the end of the band’s set, it receives a rowdy standing ovation. Pretty impressive. After all, The Avetts are just a little band on a little label, but given their edgy, inspired performance, the response is no surprise.
With the tight scheduling, you don’t get many encores at Merlefest, but the stage manager decides to avert a riot by letting the band come out and play one more. The Avetts rip through “Nothing Short of Thankful,” the catchiest song on their recent studio album Mignonette, and their newly converted fans scream while the trio thrashes about, beating their ragged instruments unmerciful. Of all the newcomers at this festival, this is the band to keep an eye on.
After acoustic Armageddon, it’s over to the Watson stage to chill on the grassy knoll down front. As the crowd waits for The Duhks to perform, the winners of Merlefest’s annual songwriting competition (which in the past has included Gillian Welch) perform their winning compositions. Sam Quinn brought home the award in the bluegrass category, and Zane Williams’ ready-for-Music Row sound landed an award for best country song (more than a little cheesy, but that’s what they dig in Nash Vegas, right?). After they run through their songs, Mike Fenders, winner in the gospel category, plays his impressive “Who’s Gonna Throw That First Stone.”
Merlefest is known for its gospel and bluegrass roots, but much like the Italian cuisine served the previous evening, organizers get a wild hair every so often. The festival usually only strays as far as Scottish, Irish, and Celtic-fused bands, but The Duhks, from Winnipeg, Manitoba, are a bit of a departure.