Modest Mouse, 'The Lonesome Crowded West' Album Review

Time Capsule: Modest Mouse, The Lonesome Crowded West

Introducing Endless Mode: A New Games & Anime Site from Paste

Read our announcement | See the 10 Best Games of 2025 (So Far)

Listen to this article

One of the most beautiful things about music is how thoroughly it can transport you into environments, headspaces, emotions, and situations you’ve never actually experienced. Mount Eerie’s A Crow Looked at Me is unimaginably devastating regardless of whether or not you have personally lost someone to cancer. You can feel the pain bleeding through the surface-level restraint and cheer of Fleetwood Mac’s Rumours even if you haven’t made an album with a partner while your very public relationship with them falls apart in real time. You don’t have to actually drink yourself to death stuck in a miserable marriage in the humid suburbia of Florida’s capital city for the Mountain Goats’ Tallahassee to resonate (hell, John Darnielle himself had never even been to Tallahassee at the time of writing the record). Modest Mouse’s breakout record is similarly transformative: When I listen to The Lonesome Crowded West, I am no longer a 23-year-old music critic whose entire life has been spent on the East Coast. For those 70-odd minutes, I become a middle-aged trucker steering my beloved 18-wheeler across the great American Midwest and sneering at the desolation that urbanization and corporatization have wrought on the landscape I’ve spent my entire adult life traversing.

Some albums define their era; others carve out a sound so distinct they create an era of their own; others transcend eras entirely, becoming something approaching evergreen, timeless. The Lonesome Crowded West, Modest Mouse’s sprawling, dust-choked roadtrip opus, does all three. A fever dream of strip malls, highways, and existential dread, the album winds its way through an American road trip of decay, its guitars lurching and swerving like an old pickup struggling to stay in its lane. Furious but restrained, cynical but searching, messy but deliberate, and of course, isolated but claustrophobic, The Lonesome Crowded West is every bit as contradictory as its title would suggest. But as time has passed, a new contradiction has emerged. The record captures the brittle disillusionment of its pre-millenium moment and drenches it in a specific, dated aesthetic of Americana that itself felt on the brink of extinction—yet despite being so evidently a product of and response to its specific cultural moment, The Lonesome Crowded West seems to have only become more prescient in the decades since its release.

Most Popular

Few albums make me feel as thoroughly American as The Lonesome Crowded West—and I mean that as an insult to the nation, but a compliment to the album. It’s hard to think of any record that so viscerally depicts the dehumanizing, dissociative sensation of urban sprawl, or even tries to. Its setting is the most American of liminal spaces: the flat grayness of I-90. Frontman Isaac Brock, who was only 22 at the time of the album’s release in 1997, had a front-row seat to the anxious, post-Nirvana disaffection settling over a generation watching their American Dreams dissolve into parking lots and payday loans. Raised in Montana before moving to Issaquah, Washington, Brock became deeply bothered by what he called “the paving of the West.” As he put it in a 2013 Pitchfork documentary on The Lonesome Crowded West: “When I got to Issaquah, the town I lived in, it started out as a cute little town, and I got to see it very quickly just get mall-fucked.” (Sidebar: we really need to incorporate “mall-fucked” into our cultural vernacular.)

America might have been sprawling needlessly, laying waste to fertile ground (literally—Brock describes a Seattle parking lot built atop what was supposedly the best soil in the nation), but there’s hardly a squandered moment across The Lonesome Crowded West. Tracks turn on a dime, jumping from furious catharsis to fragile vulnerability without missing a beat. And this isn’t the polished indie rock of the 2000s that Modest Mouse would later brush against—it’s an amalgamation of raw indie rock, Midwest emo, twangy folk, country classics, and noise rock, all quilted together effortlessly yet intentionally leaving the seams exposed. I had the pleasure of seeing the album performed in full in 2022 for its 25th anniversary tour, and can only reiterate just how smoothly everything flows. Modest Mouse winds through a route that, for all its surprises, manages to still feel predetermined and natural; it’s a singular linear journey, even though the stops along the way might be wholly unpredictable.

The album is a masterpiece of intentional instability. Songs don’t just build—they unravel. Hooks emerge only after being dragged through miles of broken asphalt and Brock’s throat-shredding howls. The band’s interplay is crucial: Jeremiah Green’s drumming shifts from propulsive to disjointed at a moment’s notice, mirroring the album’s push-pull between urgency and exhaustion—just listen to the tom rolls on “Trucker’s Atlas,” the souped-up hi-hat on “Doin’ the Cockroach,” and the hints of tambourine on “Cowboy Dan.” Eric Judy’s basslines, meanwhile, provide a woozy anchor; never showy but always essential, the glue holding the chaos together. Some of the album’s best moments stem from their interplay: Green’s kick drum locking in with Judy’s relentless groove on “Polar Opposites,” or the manic chaos of Green’s insane drumming on “It’s All Nice” held steady by the distinct rhythm of Judy’s bass. And then, of course, there’s the lyricism of Brock, which is so good it makes me genuinely angry that he wrote it at the ripe age of 22—I mean, “primer gray is the color when you’re done dying”?! Come on!

From its first notes, The Lonesome Crowded West makes its mission statement clear: this is an album about movement. For better or worse, there is no stasis; everything is always in motion, even when the motion is towards devastation. Brock downright screams as much on late-album thrasher, “Shit Luck:” “This plane is definitely crashing / This boat is obviously sinking / This building’s totally burning down / And my heart is slowly drying up!” (Quick aside: “Shit Luck” is a great song for rage and catharsis! It is also, speaking from personal experience, quite possibly the worst song conceivable to start playing on shuffle two seconds after you notice the plane you’re on is leaking water from the ceiling).

Fittingly, opener “Teeth Like God’s Shoeshine” doesn’t just start—it erupts, with Brock shouting about claustrophobic despair “from the top of the ocean / to the bottom of the sky” over a jagged, collapsing riff. Just as it seems ready to collapse under its own weight, it morphs into a quirky, radio-ready indie pop melody—then, a few lines later, melts into a slow-pulsing, campfire-like yearner of a chorus, before finally bursting into an anthemic exorcism of existential frustration. In one track, Modest Mouse display more variety than some bands manage in an entire career. Despite its frenetic shifts from hyperactive guitar stabs to sweet acoustic murmurs, nothing ever feels out of place. Each sonic movement mirrors the song’s lyrical content so precisely that it plays like a fractured, out-of-order application of the five stages of grief to late-stage capitalism. If only we could buy new friends at the grocery store. If only we could sell our conscience. But it’s “all wrong,” and it’s “all gone.”

Not every track aims for such a varied arc, nor should they. “Convenient Parking” follows a more streamlined structure, its verses building with pent-up frustration until the eventual wails of the chorus feel like an inevitable, bitter release: “Convenient parking is way back, way back!” The guitars churn like an engine struggling to start, while Brock’s voice rises in exasperation. It’s a cruel kind of irony: we built cars and roads and factories in order to maximize convenience for ourselves, and yet the most convenient parking available is somehow always “way back, way back.” Our obsession with efficiency only seems to make things less efficient in the end; we reinvent our world time and time again only to continue making the same mistakes. Even as technology and industrialization bleeds into everything we do, somehow you’re still left “feeling real dirty sitting in your car with nothing”—at least, that is, if you’re low enough on the societal totem pole to need to find parking in the first place.

It’s not like you have any other choice: You sit in your car feeling dirty because that’s what life is now. Our planes crash and our boats sink and we take them anyway. We ride public transport even though everyone on it is insufferable—as Brock groans on “Doin’ The Cockroach,” “Drunk on the Amtrak, please shut up! / Another rider, he was a talker / Talking about TV, please shut up!” We’re all just living as best we can, even when that means “rutting through garbage” and doing, apparently, a dance called the cockroach. The song rides on a jittery, hypnotic groove, like a Greyhound bus rattling over uneven pavement, and when it finally explodes into its frantic, unhinged climax, it feels less like catharsis and more like sheer exhaustion, a breakdown rather than a breakthrough—but undoubtedly a breakdance either way. As bizarre as the song is, there’s still something to that image of scuttling around in a futile dance of survival that feels oddly relevant. Desperation disguised as motion, motion disguised as purpose.

“Doin’ The Cockroach” launches one of the greatest (if not the greatest) three-song sequences in Modest Mouse’s catalog, whirling into the nihilism of “Cowboy Dan” before quieting into the plaintive vulnerability of “Trailer Trash.” “Cowboy Dan” is The Lonesome Crowded West at its most scorched-earth, opening with one of the dumbest, most perfect first lines ever: “Cowboy Dan’s a major player in the cowboy scene.” What follows is a spiral of desperation—Cowboy Dan, bitter and broken, picking fights with God in the desert, demanding retribution from the sky, only to be met with silence. The song burns hot from the start, carrying the final eruption of “Doin’ The Cockroach,” before sinking into a rare moment of exhausted reflection: “Standing in the tall grass, thinking nothing / You know we need oxygen to breathe.” Then, like clockwork, the cycle restarts—rage flaring, drums pounding, Brock spitting the same refrain: “Every time you think you’re walking, you’re just moving the ground.” The frontier isn’t a mythic escape. It’s barren, hostile—a place where you can’t even get your damn engine turned over. (Although, admittedly, I am physically incapable of hearing that line as anything but “can’t get that egg to turn over,” so my mental image for the song has always been a drunk cowboy watching this YouTube tutorial and crying. But really, that only enhances the experience.)

“Trailer Trash” is the bruised heart of the album, all that rage and cynicism stripped away to reveal something deeply personal and self-lacerating. It’s raw, personal, and uncomfortably honest, soaked in young, aching self-awareness (“Goddamn, I hope I can pass / High school means nothing”). The lyrics are a masterclass in simplicity and weight: “Eating snowflakes with plastic forks / And a paper plate, of course / You think of everything.” It’s a song about class, about failure, about relationships that erode into nothing, and the helpless cycle of it all: “A short love with a long divorce / And a couple of kids, of course / They don’t mean anything.” The music mirrors the feeling, locked into a repetitive, hypnotic progression that feels like being stuck in place even as time moves forward. As Brock sings at the close of the song: “It’s been a long time / Which agrees with this watch of mine / And I know that I miss you / And I’m sorry if I dissed you.” It’s so simple, so real, almost childlike in its honesty, like a memory unraveling in real time, an entire adolescence condensed into three and a half minutes of looping chords and quiet regret.

Speaking of loops—see “Trucker’s Atlas,” a 10-minute ode to perpetual motion for its own sake, the desperate, fevered need to keep moving even when there’s nowhere to go. Modest Mouse lock into a groove so airtight it practically keeps the wheels spinning, with Green’s drums clicking past like mile markers, Judy’s bassline looping in a trance, and Brock’s guitar twitching between sharp chords and wiry single-note runs. “I’m going to Colorado to unload my head,” Brock yells, launching into an itinerary that feels less like a plan and more like an anxious compulsion—New York, Arizona, Alaska, anywhere but here. But cracks start to show in the bravado. The metaphor soon splinters; roads become state lines, boundaries, and chemical indulgences all blurring together. The song itself becomes a loop, its final six minutes circling the same hypnotic riffs, the same rhythms, the same nervous energy that can’t quite break free. Brock sings, “Do you speak the lingo? No, no! / How far does your road go? Oh, no, you don’t know!” before vaulting right back into his cross-country itinerary, caught in the same restless cycle. It’s not freedom, it’s just another stretch of pavement disappearing in the rearview.

But if The Lonesome Crowded West has a moment of pure, gut-wrenching devastation, it’s “Bankrupt on Selling.” Everything about it—the stripped-down acoustics, the delicate melody, the way Brock’s voice wavers like it might crack at any moment—feels raw and fragile, teetering on the edge of breaking apart completely. Everything is for sale: religion, love, even souls. The Apostles sell their Savior for “some sandals with the style of straps that cling best to the era” (Birkenstocks, perhaps?), businesses buy and sell until they’re “bankrupt on selling,” angels pawn off souls for sets of new wings. You go to college, learn some big words, attempt to do something, make a difference, but in the end it’s just as pointless as anything else—all people will remember is “the guy that said all those big words / he must’ve learned in college. The most gutting moment comes in the final verse: “I still love her, loved her more / When she used to be sober and I was kinder.” It’s an unbearable realization, the quiet death of love with no way to bring it back. And it’s not only love that’s lost; it’s the past, the happier past, that seems to have dissipated as if into thin air.

The closing track, “Styrofoam Boots/It’s All Nice On Ice, Alright,” seems to center that same question of what happens to the loves and pasts and people who succumb to death. The song starts out folky, jaunty, almost playful—a sharp contrast with its lyrics: “You’ll be drowned in boots like mafia / But your feet will still float like Christ’s.” After this unceremonious end, the speaker goes up to heaven, “trying to figure out which stack / They’re going to stuff us atheists into.” Heaven isn’t quite the mythical place of peace we often imagine it as; as the religious allusions in “Bankrupt on Selling” seemed to suggest, even heaven is just another business, another corporate machine. Atheists are immediately put to work “polishing halos, baking manna and gas” in the back room. God himself (slick-looking, smelling like Listerine, “looking a bit like everyone I ever seen”) is nothing more than a CEO, bemoaning the prayers flooding his line: “Any time anyone gets on their knees to pray / Well, it makes my telephone ring.”

He seems to instruct the speaker to, essentially, pull himself up by his bootstraps, because it’s his responsibility to do so, not God’s: “God takes care of himself, and you of you.” Then the drums hit, and the song spirals into frantic, frenzied absurdity, culminating in its final, bitter punchline: “It’s all nice on ice!” “On ice” can mean preserved, frozen in place, but it also means dead, gone. In this sense, it really does feel like a callback to the first line of the track (about being told that getting iced by the mafia will “all be quite nice”) but turned into a mantra, repeated over and over again, almost as if it’s a corporate motto advertising an afterlife that, in actuality, is just as indifferent as everything else. Heaven isn’t salvation; it’s just another slogan, another lie sold to keep us all in line. But at least it’s catchy!

This—death, being put on ice—is the only real stasis presented in the constant movement of The Lonesome Crowded West. We will only ever get older, and things will only ever get stranger and more unfamiliar—and rapidly so. As Brock puts it on the underrated second track “Heart Cooks Brain”: “In this life that we call home / The years go fast and the days go slow / The days go so slow.” Life as we know it now might feel hollow and empty, but once it’s gone, replaced by a new one, there will be a sense of loss. “We tore one down and erected another there,” he sings. “The match of the century, absence versus thin air.” The world we’re so disillusioned by today will one day be something we miss, and that is perhaps the most devastating realization of all.

The Lonesome Crowded West doesn’t just critique modern Americana; it inhabits it, rolling through its streets, sleeping in its motels, choking on its exhaust. In the decades since its release, its themes have only become more prescient, its landscapes more familiar. The west has only gotten more crowded, the lonesomeness more profound. The record manages to grieve the loss of the past, future, and present all at once—to mourn the fruitlessness of trying to “find out the beginning, the end, and the best of it,” to quote “Teeth Like God’s Shoeshine.” There’s no one answer in any of them. It’s all worth it, and it’s all wrong, and it’s all gone, all at once.

Perhaps that’s why, listening to the record now, it feels like Isaac Brock taps into a nostalgia for a past that didn’t even exist yet—a nostalgia for our past, which was their present. Perhaps that’s why, when Brock croons about Orange Julius a few lines down, it almost feels like he knows something we don’t—like he’s telling us to stand in those long lines and buy another one of those budget creamsicle drinks precisely because he knows that the very next year, in 1998, Warren Buffet will buy the chain and slowly rebrand all surviving, non-shopping mall Orange Julius stores into Dairy Queens add-ons; that, in 2019, Dairy Queen will finally turn Orange Julius into a menu-only drink, and almost nothing of the brand will remain; that one day all of it will be gone, and when it is, we might miss it.

“The malls are the soon-to-be ghost towns,” Brock sings on the opening track, hushed and earnest, a send-off to a future that, back when he wrote the song in 1997, hadn’t come yet. Of course, for us listening now in 2025, it already has. By now, it feels like there are more dead malls around than living ones, the entirety of the culture replaced by the convenience of an Amazon delivery in one fell swoop. But even so, now as then, there’s nothing else we can do but the cockroach, but sing along with Brock’s warm melody: “So long, farewell, goodbye.”

Casey Epstein-Gross is an Assistant Music Editor at Paste. Her work can be read in Observer, Jezebel, and elsewhere. She is based in New York and can typically be found subjecting innocent bystanders to rambling, long-winded monologues about television and film, music, politics, and any number of opinions on bizarrely irrelevant topics. Follow her on X (@epsteingross) or email her at [email protected].

Time Capsule: Modest Mouse, The Lonesome Crowded West

The PNW band’s second album is a masterpiece of intentional instability. Songs don’t just build, they unravel; hooks emerge only after being dragged through miles of broken asphalt and Isaac Brock’s throat-shredding howls.