“I’m talking about who we are, ‘cause that’s the reason we do what we do.”-Hunter Mosley
They say that you should judge a man by his actions, not his words. Graham Yost and the creative team behind Justified certainly seem to think so. They’re in the midst of making a television show to prove their point. Character as destiny has been their thesis all season, and this week’s episode is the beginning of their closing statement.
As we very nearly knew last week, Sheriff Shelby is indeed the secret identity of ill-fated skydiving thief Drew Thompson. Given the heavy-handed clues that were dropped last week, the reveal is hardly a revelation. What is revelatory, however, is what we learn in the process.
Take Hunter Mosley, for instance. It was easy to assume that his decision to kill Arlo was a completely despicable act committed at the behest of a criminal kingpin. Even more important, consider what drove Arlo to both kill and die to protect Drew’s identity. We had been led to believe all season that his motivation was predictably sinister, an angle that would benefit him in some way whether it was money or freedom.
As it turns out, we were wrong about both men and their true intentions were nobler than we ever could have suspected.
Then again, misjudged motivations are all over this episode. When Raylan calls in a favor in order to personally transport Mosley, we automatically assumed, along with a hysterical Art (both the angry and funny kinds), that Raylan has some vengeance in mind. It speaks volumes about Raylan as a character and the job that the creative team has done over the years developing not only the man but also his locale and heritage that we have no problem imagining him avenging a man that he despised.
Here again, we were wrong.
Just like we were wrong when we thought that Boyd would kill Colt for lying about Ellen May (though with three hours yet to play out this season, I wouldn’t buy any green bananas if I were Colt). Just like we were wrong when we thought Drew/Shelby would kill Mosley in order to protect his identity once and for all. Just like we were wrong when we thought that Sister Cassie was nothing but a pretender and a con artist.
In the end, Arlo and Mosley were trying to kill each other for the same reason: to protect Drew. Though it remains unclear exactly how the debt originated for Arlo, the way Mosley and Shelby talk about Raylan’s mother, it seems likely that it has something to do with her. It isn’t the first time we have heard a character speak of Francis with a level of affection and respect that approaches worship and none more so than Raylan. Still she remains an elusive figure, her name always spoken with sadness and praise. If all she did to deserve such admiration was to call a truce meeting, then that must have been some meeting. I’m not convinced that Arlo would have ever gone through with his deal, which is a surprising thing to say. Mostly I just think there has to have been a good reason for Arlo to keep that courier bag in his wall all those years, and I refuse to believe it had anything to do with money. Otherwise Arlo would have cashed it in long ago.