Lapis Might Be Back, But It’s Still The Peridot Show On Steven Universe
(Episode 3.04)

Well, now. Remember last week, when Steven talked about how Lapis Lazuli could move to Empire City, get a job at a local coffee shop and come home to a wacky roommate?
Turns out he’s at least one-third prophetic; Peridot is super wacky. And we got to see that full wackiness on display in “Barn Mates.” Let’s dive into the details of an episode equal parts full of laughter and cringes.
Peridot’s a Crystal Gem, but she’s not her own gem.
A couple weeks ago, I wrote that Peridot had finally become one of the Crystal Gems, fully forsaking the cold reason of Homeworld for the emotional depth of Earth. It was a great start, but that’s all it was: a start. If we learned anything from “Barn Mates,” it’s that Peridot remains a relative child without an independent identity. And that’s particularly problematic for her relationship with Lapis Lazuli, who still sees her as “that jerk who interrogated me,” the reason she can’t go back to Homeworld. “It’s different!” Peridot pleads. “I’m different now!” But Peridot struggles to show exactly how she’s changed, because all she really is right now is a clean slate.
Peridot’s thirst for approval pervades this episode, from her repeated outreach to Lapis, to her subtle adoption of Amethyst’s mannerisms. (If it wasn’t obvious enough from her delivery of “I got yo number,” how about the fact that Peridot and Amethyst both respond to the crashed Homeworld ship with a big ol’ “Holy smokes.”) It’s hard to blame her, because, ever since she befriended Steven, Peridot has had love and attention lavished upon her. After so long on Homeworld without any of that TLC, she’s probably addicted to the positivity.
I was an overnight camp counselor for six summers, and right now, Peridot reminds me of the campers I’ve had who thrive on counselor praise. It’s sometimes a delicate task to handle these kids, since they’re often the ones who used to be the absolute worst, and are out to prove to everyone that they’ve gotten better. Give them too much approval, and their improvement could become contingent solely on extrinsic rather than intrinsic motivation; shoot them down too hard, and they could go right back to being the absolute worst. The way to approach the situation is to gently encourage them to keep up the empathy, while emphasizing to them that behavior, not words, is what really changes people’s minds. To win people over, I always told these campers, they had to stop defining themselves in the negative and carve out a new identity through their actions. That’s what Peridot needs to do if she’s truly committed to change.
The attempts Peridot makes at empathy throughout “Barn Mates” are hilariously misguided—unlike Lapis, we find them endearing because we know Peridot’s still in the early stages of deprogramming from her Homeworld mentality. She’s new to this whole “feelings” business. But this episode really hits home when Steven suggests that Peridot give Lapis something of her own, and Peridot decides to hand over her tape recorder. The tape recorder is essentially all of Peridot’s identity here on Earth—or, rather, it’s a receptacle into which Peridot dumped her entire old self. Without it, she’s not even defined in the negative anymore; she’s just Peridot, a lost soul on this beautiful, lonely planet.
So when Lapis crushes the tape recorder and calls it “garbage,” then tells Peridot to leave, what’s really happened?
1. Peridot realizes a cold, hard fact about Earth: some people will always hate you.
2. Peridot heads off over the hills to finally become her own gem.
I was sort of shocked at the grace with which Peridot handled Lapis’ rejection, and it’s probably a defining moment for her as a character. In her facial expression, you can see her almost literally swallowing her pride, her loneliness, and her overwhelming desire to be loved. And at the same time, Peridot sees that she’s going to have to cut her own Gem on Earth, just as Lapis will have to do.
It would have been fascinating to see Peridot figuring out a new life for herself on her own, but alas, that’s not going to happen with this Homeworld ship in the picture. She’ll probably be just as needy, and just as adorable, until they’re gone.