Steamy Psychological Thriller The Couple Next Door Fails to Catch Fire
Photo: Courtesy of Starz
Suburbia is a weirdly liminal space. Neither the city nor the country, it’s both idyllic and foreboding, a symbol of success whose flawless veneer often hides dark secrets underneath and where anything can happen behind closed doors. That’s the general premise behind Starz’s steamy thriller The Couple Next Door, a story that wants to dig into this facade through the stories of two very different couples and the tangled relationship that develops between them. But while it’s clear that the series wants to be provocative and edgy while doing so, its exploration of the complexities of modern-day relationships never quite manages to do more than simmer.
Based on the Dutch series Nieuwe Burn, The Couple Next Door follows the story of primary school teacher Evie (Eleanor Tomlinson) and her journalist husband Pete (Alfred Enoch) as they move into a new home in a picture-perfect suburban neighborhood and are immediately befriended by their hot neighbors, traffic cop Danny (Sam Heughan) and his yoga instructor wife Becka (Jessica De Gouw). As the youngest people on their street, the foursome find themselves immediately spending time together, and it’s apparent that Evie finds the other couple fascinating for many reasons—not the least of which is that she’s very obviously attracted to Danny.
Things intensify when Danny and Becka reveal that they’re in a non-traditional relationship, and frequently invite other couples into their bedroom for some extramarital fun. Evie, who hails from a conservative religious family and has only ever been with Pete, romantically speaking, finds this all fascinating—and very tempting. As her curiosity about their lifestyle grows, so does her urge to do some experimentation herself and give in to the sort of desires she’s always been taught are sinful. Pete, for his part, is less into the concept of swinging, and his reluctance to open up their marriage leads to new and increased tensions in his relationship with his wife.
The Couple Next Door is at its most interesting and entertaining when it’s teasing out the messy relationship between this foursome. As various members of the group debate whether they should all sleep together, discuss the rules of non-monogamy, or dance drunkenly on the seashore together, it’s all so much escapist fun. The cast is attractive, the moral questions are suitably complicated, and the steadily building tension as our leads (namely Evie) spiral further into obsession adds an exciting frisson of danger to many scenes. The steadily unfolding drama between the couples is addictive and offers multiple opportunities for some surprisingly nuanced conversations about modern relationship dynamics.
This show can feel like a peak ‘90s erotic thriller in its best moments, but throughout its six episodes (all of which were available for review) it frequently undercuts its own momentum by focusing on multiple dull and, quite frankly, completely unnecessary subplots. Danny’s financial worries lead him to take on a few extracurricular jobs of the less-than-legal variety, of precisely the sort that Pete’s busy digging into during his investigation into local corruption at work. Elsewhere, a creeptastic neighbor (Hugh Dennis) is busy stalking Becka, in a story that frequently feels as though it’s happening on a different show entirely. None of these secondary threads are remotely as interesting or scandalous as the show seems to think they are, and every time a scene cuts away from the messy emotional entanglement between the two leading couples, it might as well be accompanied by the sound of a balloon deflating.
The series is also plagued by pacing problems, spending the front half of its season building up a tension we barely get a chance to see the fallout from. Its finale, which takes a sharp turn into the violent and absurd, feels like a cop-out ending for a show that started out at least giving lip service to the idea of things like nuance. As the characters—except for Becka, who remains this story’s surprisingly mature MVP—steadily regress into the worst, most stereotypical versions of themselves the story becomes increasingly cliche-ridden and clumsy, bonkers in a way that’s simply unbelievable rather than transgressive or even simply fun to watch.
To their credit, the series’ main quartet gamely battles to make the most of what they’re given. Tomlinson is excellent as a classic good girl given the chance to explore her innermost desires in ways she never thought possible. Evie’s deeply religious background—and the psychological damage it so clearly caused—offers some potentially fascinating layers to her character, but the series does little more than use it as an excuse for her repression, as her sexual awakening rapidly devolves into uncomfortable cliche and her infatuation with Danny intensifies.
Heughan, beloved by many for his turn as hunky historical wife guy Jamie Fraser in Outlander, gets little of substance to do here beyond brood attractively. He has serviceable chemistry with both Tomlinson and De Gouw, but despite keeping plenty of secrets, Danny has almost no interiority to speak of. Enoch fares little better, as his initially level-headed Pete quickly spirals into jealousy, to a degree that the series barely even bothers to explain, let alone justify. But it is De Gouw who is The Couple Next Door’s most welcome surprise, crafting a version of Becka who not only feels like the most responsible adult on the block but is also the only character who experiences any sort of genuine growth.
Overstuffed with supporting characters whose names you won’t remember and subplots you won’t care about, The Couple Next Door squanders the genuinely interesting tension between the characters at its center in favor of a confrontational, tonally jarring ending that doesn’t even entirely make sense. If this mess between the characters was at least fun to watch that’d be one thing. But most people will just be relieved to get out of this neighborhood as fast as possible.
The Couple Next Door premieres Friday, January 17 on Starz.
Lacy Baugher Milas is the Books Editor at Paste Magazine, but loves nerding out about all sorts of pop culture. You can find her on Twitter and Bluesky at @LacyMB
For all the latest TV news, reviews, lists and features, follow @Paste_TV