The Performances That Define Tom Ripley, Past and Present
Photo Courtesy of Netflix
In the world of Tom Ripley, things are never black and white. At least, they weren’t, until Netflix’s new series Ripley. Ever since Ripley first appeared in the pages of Patricia Highsmith’s iconic 1955 novel The Talented Mr. Ripley, his has been a story of moral ambiguity, of gray areas, of hidden alleyways shrouded in shadow. Clearly, this walking enigma struck a chord. Not only did Highsmith go on to write four subsequent novels about Ripley, but there have been numerous adaptations on stage and screen. The most notable of these, of course, came in 1999 from Academy Award winning director Anthony Minghella, whose film version of Highsmith’s first novel served as the breakout vehicle for such stars as Matt Damon, Jude Law, and Gwenyth Paltrow. In addition to Damon, the role has been taken on by such heavyweights as Dennis Hopper and John Malkovich, and now falls to Andrew Scott, whose recent work in Fleabag and 2023’s All Of Us Strangers has led to a well-deserved breakout. It isn’t difficult to see why such a coterie of performers would want to delve into the mind of Tom Ripley, a character as slippery as they come, both whatever you want him to be and yet nothing at all—a performance of a lifetime.
So much of Ripley’s story, past and present, has been about performance, and that holds true with Ripley. When we first meet Tom, in 1960’s New York City, he is playing the part of the con-man, to decidedly mixed results. He is getting by, but barely; his dilapidated apartment and half-baked schemes a far cry from the life he longs to lead. When an opportunity presents itself in the form of shipping magnate Herbert Greenleaf, he doesn’t hesitate, quickly becoming just what it is the old man needs from him: a lifeline to his estranged, globe-trotting, trust-fund sucking son Dickie (Johnny Flynn). And yet, when he arrives in the idyllic, Italian city of Atrani, he quickly changes his tune, dropping the ruse presented to him by Herbert and entering another, revealing the true nature of his mission to Dickie and endearing himself to his new friend. Of course, not even this is the whole truth. To Dickie, and his doting girlfriend Marge (Dakota Fanning), Tom is an accountant who Dickie might or might not have known at Princeton, not a con-man at the end of his rope with all his belongings shoved in a few suitcases.
From there Dickie and Tom enter into a kind of courtship, bonding over Dickie’s love of the finer things in life. Here you can see, thanks to Scott’s wonderful subtleties, the seeds of a new kind of performance taking shape. Tom reveals almost nothing about himself that will undercut their growing friendship, instead grafting his own personality onto Dickie’s, becoming the friend and confidant that Dickie seemingly desires, playing the mirror. Of course, we soon get the moment when Ripley very much loses the cool that has defined him to that point. Despite all his work to ingratiate himself in his life, Dickie has clearly had enough of Tom’s needy presence. This is only further exasperated when he finds Tom in a rare moment of vulnerability. Believing himself to be alone, Tom is wearing Dickie’s clothes, in fact pretending to be Dickie, sauntering in front of the mirror and impersonating his speech patterns. This is an essential scene in every version of The Talented Mr. Ripley and so too here, an example of Ripley’s innate longing made plain in a performance that goes further than even he might have expected.